Five Washington County judges took a difficult and honorable step when they sought assistance dealing with a colleague, mercurial President Judge Debbie O’Dell Seneca.

The state Supreme Court intervened, relieving the judge of her administrative duties and assigning them temporarily to Senior Judge Joseph James of Allegheny County.

On Dec. 30 Judge O’Dell Seneca announced she would retire today. At 61, and only partway into her third term, she could have served as a full-time judge for several more years, but her departure comes not a moment too soon.

Long viewed as needlessly heavy-handed, Judge O’Dell Seneca became embroiled in a number of controversies in recent years, including allegations that she altered court transcripts and used a sophisticated courthouse sound system to eavesdrop on private conversations. She’s also named in a whistleblower lawsuit, filed by a former juvenile probation officer who complained of mismanagement.

Advertise with us

It is not known whether these issues or something else prompted the county’s other judges — Katherine B. Emery, Gary Gilman, Valarie Costanzo, Michael Lucas and John DiSalle — to seek the Supreme Court’s help in November. Their decision could not have been easy, but it spoke volumes about their commitment to the court’s integrity.

Their action also yielded an immediate dividend. After Judge James was brought in to handle administrative matters, the five said, the court’s morale and functioning improved.

In a statement on her retirement, Judge O’Dell Seneca thanked voters for “entrusting” her with the honor of serving them for 23 years. At least her colleagues have demonstrated a firm grasp of that sacred trust.

Meet the Editorial Board.