The Pennsylvania Legislature has earned its terrible reputation. The leadership’s portrait gallery includes four convicted felons. More than a dozen lawmakers have been convicted of wrongdoing in the past 15 years. Two more representatives were charged with bribery just this month, and the investigation into two of their colleagues continues.
It’s the sort of cesspool that cries out for tight rules and diligent oversight, but a comprehensive report by the Post-Gazette’s Joe Smydo demonstrates that’s just not happening. The General Assembly’s questionable ethics take many forms.
• There are no restrictions on outside income.
The majority of legislators — 36 of the 50 senators and more than half of the 203 representatives — have at least one source beyond their state paychecks. That’s disappointing considering that the public provides lawmakers with enviable, full-time pay and benefits — an average of $84,000 with more for leaders, plus expenses and per diems when they’re in Harrisburg.
More troubling is that lawmakers don’t have to say how much outside income they receive overall or the sums they reap from each source.
The effort of Democratic Rep. Anthony DeLuca of Penn Hills to cap outside income at 35 percent of lawmakers’ state salaries has failed — no surprise. Since members won’t agree to limits, the least they can do is follow New York state’s lead and specify an income range for each source — $1,000 to $4,999, $5,000 to $19,999 and so on.
• Lawmakers can vote their personal interests.
The public has no way of knowing whether lawmakers are helping themselves financially when they cast votes.
Take the example of Republican Mike Brubaker, who left office last month after two terms as a senator from Lancaster County. Through his role on the Agriculture and Rural Affairs Committee, he voted on legislation affecting a project in which his firm, TeamAg, had a role.
Or the two state lawmakers — Republican Sen. Robert Tomlinson of Bucks County and Democratic Rep. Harry Readshaw of Carrick — both funeral directors who sit on committees that oversee professional licensure and influence policies that apply to their businesses.
Or Sen. Elder Vogel, R-Beaver County, and representatives Pam Snyder, D-Greene County, and Jim Marshall, R-Beaver County, all of whom hold gas leases but insist that the lease payments don’t guide their votes on energy policy. With so many members in the General Assembly, couldn’t they have abstained?
Recusals are a rarity in the Legislature. The Post-Gazette could find evidence of just three in the House during a 20-month period. The Senate provided only 15 examples of members asking whether they should abstain during a three-year period and in every case that body’s presiding officer told them to go ahead and vote.
That included Charles McIlhinney, a Bucks County Republican, who voted on the appointment of his mother to a $57,000-a-year seat on a state board.
• Oversight is secretive and toothless.
The public has no way of knowing how many ethics complaints are made against which members. The House and Senate ethics committees — responsible for investigating complaints, initiating inquiries and holding members accountable — won’t release records. They don’t even report who shows up for required ethics training.
The Pennsylvania State Ethics Commission, charged with enforcing ethics laws, doesn’t do much better. In most cases, it cannot fine offenders, and it has only limited subpoena power. If a prosecutor investigates a member but determines no crime was committed, the commission can’t see the records to determine if an ethical violation took place.
What’s the answer?
Start with more detailed reporting. The public needs to know how much money lawmakers are getting paid from businesses and organizations.
Next, lawmakers should take those associations into account and voluntarily refrain from voting far more often than happens today.
Finally, the ethics committees must provide regular updates on complaints they receive and investigations they initiate, and the state ethics commission needs more independent authority.
The Legislature has a long way to go to clean itself up.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.