For such an anticipated policy change, Attorney General Eric Holder Jr.’s new framework on racial profiling is disappointing.
Arriving amid nationwide protests against questionable policing, the guidelines offer commendable reforms to profiling in routine, spontaneous police stops. But agencies that are notorious for relying on profiling, such as airport security and the Border Patrol, will mostly be allowed to go about their business as usual.
The new guidelines ban profiling not just by race, but also by national origin, gender, religion, sexual orientation and gender identity during routine law-enforcement stops, except when one of the characteristics is used to identify a specific suspect. The guidelines also set stricter standards for national and homeland security investigations, which will be allowed to use identity-based factors if they have reliable information that connects people “possessing a particular listed characteristic” to specific illegal activities.
The previous guidelines gave national security investigators free rein to profile by race to the extent permitted by the Constitution, and left it to their discretion to determine what that meant. The new framework clarifies the scope of racial profiling that is considered reasonable, but it’s still broad enough to permit virtually any instance of profiling.
Racial profiling erodes trust between law enforcement and minority communities, and its effectiveness is unproven. Because the guidelines apply only to federal agencies, not to local or state police, most Americans’ day-to-day interactions with police will be unaffected. But if police departments hope to rebuild their trust with citizens, now is the time to review their policies, too.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.