The Pittsburgh Planning Commission made the wrong decision last Tuesday when members voted in favor of a new requirement for housing developments.

The proposed legislation, sponsored by city Councilman R. Daniel Lavelle, says any builder in a so-called planned district who accepts public subsidies or uses public land would have to make an effort to ensure that 30 percent of the units are affordable.

There are a lot of problems with the proposed change, which requires city council approval, starting with its vague language. It doesn’t define key terms including what constitutes “commercially reasonable efforts” to achieve the 30 percent or what “affordable” is.

Then there is that figure itself. The city, its housing authority, Hill District community groups and the Pittsburgh Penguins spent more than a year negotiating an agreement that covers the housing component of the team’s development plan, and the 30 percent level for lower-cost housing was a key sticking point. Developers say they can’t make a go of it with that proportion of lower-income units, and the fact that parties to the Pens’ deal settled on 20 percent suggests they’re right.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lavelle’s assurance that the figure is not a mandate but a goal only reinforces the point that the legislation is too vague.

Another problem has to do with where the provisions would come into play. Although the legislation says it won’t apply to projects that already have been designated as “specifically planned” — Station Square on the South Side and Bakery Square in East Liberty are examples — it could apply to the Penguins’ site around Consol Energy Center, which doesn’t have that label.

The city needs to use the zoning and development regulations on the books to make sure any new projects work for the whole community. That means there must be housing options across the spectrum of family income levels, but it also means Pittsburgh can’t set impossibly high standards that serve only to scare developers away.

Meet the Editorial Board.