When U.S. District Judge Arthur J. Schwab ruled last Tuesday that President Barack Obama’s executive order on immigration is unconstitutional, he became the first jurist to pass judgment on the controversial side-stepping of Congress.
But being first isn’t the same thing as being best.
It was inevitable that the president’s order would give rise to legal challenges. Beyond the broader questions about the status of undocumented immigrants, the fact that the president used his executive authority instead of waiting for Congress to enact a law made court battles a certainty. That’s one reason the nation would be better off if lawmakers would pass a bill that Mr. Obama could sign.
But just as Mr. Obama decided not to wait for Congress to act, Judge Schwab decided not to wait for the right case on which to make a ruling.
His 38-page decision came in the case of a Honduran apprehended in Beaver County. In October, before the president’s Nov. 20 order, Elionardo Juarez-Escobar pleaded guilty to re-entering the country illegally after being deported in 2005. The Justice Department has said the president’s policy does not apply in criminal cases, and neither Mr. Escobar’s lawyer nor the prosecutor raised the issue.
Nonetheless, the judge, on his own, asked both lawyers to submit briefs on whether they think the defendant is affected by the change.
Judge Schwab, who also took the unusual step of inviting other parties to weigh in, gave Mr. Escobar until Jan. 6 to decide whether to withdraw his guilty plea. The judge wrote that the defendant might be unfairly harmed by the immigration policy if it is implemented, because it gives rights to some undocumented immigrants but not others.
But most of the judge’s opinion is devoted to the larger point, calling Mr. Obama’s order an unconstitutional, “unilateral legislative action.”
In all likelihood, cases will come along that eventually will put that question before the U.S. Supreme Court. But the one before Judge Schwab didn’t require an answer to the question of constitutionality. Instead, Judge Schwab’s ruling reads like an argument from someone who was itching to get involved in a national debate. He used the wrong case to get there.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.