Philadelphia’s district attorney filed criminal charges Tuesday against two Democratic legislators, bad news for them and worse news for state Attorney General Kathleen Kane.
Pennsylvania’s top prosecutor, who last year shut down the political corruption investigation into members of her own Democratic Party, has been embarrassed by another prosecutor, DA Seth Williams.
Although he, like the targets of the probe, also is a Democrat, that didn’t stop Mr. Williams from vigorously pursuing the case against Ronald Waters, a member of the state House since 1999, and Vanessa Lowery Brown, who joined the House in 2009. Both are charged with conspiracy, bribery and other crimes, with Mr. Waters accused of accepting $8,750 in nine payments from 2010 and 2012, and Ms. Brown accused of taking five payments totaling $4,000.
Even after she abandoned the case, Ms. Kane — who has made a series of big mistakes since taking office two years ago — had predicted Mr. Williams would fail and that the case would be “dead on arrival.” Wrong again.
The grand jury presentment spells out a strong case against the two lawmakers and, more troubling, against Ms. Kane herself. Although she has said no case could be made because the confidential informant used by investigators would not be believable, the presentment noted there are extensive audio and video recordings in which the defendants are heard accepting cash. In one, Mr. Waters is heard flipping through the bills.
Ms. Kane also claimed the investigation was racist because the targets are African-Americans. DA Williams, who also is black, said the grand jury found that assertion to be false and said it was “like pouring gasoline on a fire for no reason, no reason at all.”
The loudest argument against Ms. Kane’s decision came from Mr. Waters and Ms. Brown themselves; both testified before the grand jury and fully admitted their wrongdoing. They could see the writing on the wall. Why couldn’t Ms. Kane?
Two other Philadelphia-area representatives remain under investigation and a former traffic court judge there, charged last month, has agreed to plead guilty. Mr. Waters and Ms. Brown may do the same.
Even with successful prosecutions, however, this case is hardly satisfying from a public standpoint. Instead, taxpayers and voters are left — again — scratching their heads and trying to figure out whether it is ineptitude or something else that has left Ms. Kane unable to do her job.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.