The demonstrations in Hong Kong against Beijing rule that played out for some 75 days have been brought to an end by Chinese authorities.
For the most fervent of the demonstrators it was a defeat. They did not get what they sought, which was a commitment from Chinese officials that Beijing would not determine the two or three candidates that Hong Kong voters would see on the ballot in 2017 for chief executive, succeeding Leung Chun-ying.
They had to give up six weeks of protests in the face of Beijing resoluteness, because the residents of Hong Kong were losing patience with their blocking traffic in downtown Hong Kong and because their own numbers were dwindling. The demonstrations started in September with hundreds of thousands in the streets. At the end, 209 were arrested.
At the same time, Chinese authorities lost some ground through the demonstrations. First, the protests were evidence that Beijing’s rule is neither absolute nor universally accepted, in spite of the general prosperity of the country. In addition to Hong Kong, President Xi Jinping’s government also faces continued resistance in the West among the Muslim Uighurs, from Tibetans and among religious minorities such as the Falun Gong.
To the credit of the Beijing government, it did not confront the demonstrators, as it did in Tiananmen Square in 1989, with the People’s Liberation Army or much violence in general. No one died in Hong Kong, neither protesters nor security forces.
What the protesters were calling the Umbrella Movement, because demonstrators opened umbrellas to protect against police pepper spray, is apparently over for the moment. But the support their efforts gained, not just from students but from many others in Hong Kong, made its point and argued the need for Beijing to take Hong Kong residents’ views into account on future decisions. Perhaps even more to the point, the rest of China no doubt was watching Hong Kong’s unrest as well.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.