Allegheny County restaurant owners, like stubborn diners who won’t try anything new, are refusing to swallow the health department’s proposed A-B-C grading plan.
The latest opposition in the long-running quest for a system that the public can clearly understand came during a public hearing Wednesday as county council considers whether to approve the plan.
County solicitor Andrew Szefi swatted away one claim that’s been raised, that the county doesn’t have the authority under state law to impose it. Council member Sue Means had requested his advice, and he concluded the plan is “perfectly legal” and characterized the assertion to the contrary as “a red herring.”
Whether pickled or smoked, herring and any other food for sale to the public must be prepared and stored in clean kitchens at the proper temperature. Those and other safety standards would remain unchanged under the proposed new system; the only thing that would change is that restaurants will be assigned a letter grade based on their compliance.
According to the results of the county’s second six-week pilot program, the majority of restaurants are doing a good job. In 502 inspections, 77 percent of restaurants received an A and, of the 127 that had follow-up inspections, 91 percent of those then got As, too. Those results prove that the standards are not set at unattainably high levels.
Under the plan, restaurants won’t have to worry about a bad grade going on their doors before they have a chance to make improvements for the first full year. In that inaugural period, they’d have 14 days to upgrade their performance before a grade lower than an A would be posted. In future years, the grades will go up immediately, but they could be changed based on successful re-checks.
Grading plans like the one proposed for Allegheny County are in effect in other places, including New York City. During the past four years, the plan has undergone significant modifications based on input from restaurants, safety experts and the public. Now it should be enacted.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.