A grave sin in journalism is failing to report all sides of a controversy. At a time when social media and Comedy Central-style fake news are competing with traditional news organizations as the chief source of information for young people, mainstream journalism has had to reinvent itself to appeal to readers.

Sometimes the attempt at relevance comes at the expense of journalistic integrity. Last month, Rolling Stone magazine published a story by Sabrina Rubin Erdely about an alleged gang rape of a first-year student identified by the pseudonym “Jackie” at a fraternity house at the University of Virginia in 2012.

The intent of Ms. Erdely’s story was to highlight the prevalence of sexual assault on college campuses. She built the tale around a student who claimed she had been raped by seven fraternity brothers who, because of their privilege and UVA’s indifference, have escaped justice.

It’s a compelling narrative with one drawback: It isn’t true. After Rolling Stone published one of its most widely discussed stories in years, The Washington Post did its own investigating and found that huge elements didn’t hold up.

Advertise with us

Ms. Erdely did not interview the alleged rapists because Jackie forbade it. That should have been a red flag to Rolling Stone editors that the story, since retracted by the magazine, was fatally flawed. No reporter would let a subject dictate whom she could or could not interview.

To say that Rolling Stone’s journalism was shoddy would be an understatement. And because sexual assault on campus is a subject receiving much national attention, the article is a particular disservice.

If journalism has any value, it derives from being an objective record of the conflicts that define Americans’ personal and national circumstances. It can’t afford to be one-sided. While that may limit its appeal and “relevance” for many, collecting all the facts is a non-negotiable obligation for true journalists.

Meet the Editorial Board.