College disciplinary boards are responsible for determining whether a student who is accused of misconduct can remain on campus. They need to develop and follow consistent guidelines for dealing with student offenses, on and off college grounds.

Too often, though, these boards address cases that the criminal justice system is better equipped to handle. And too often, they seem to be making it up as they go along.

An investigation by the Columbus Dispatch and the Student Press Law Center concluded that campus judicial systems tend to operate in secret and impose light sanctions for serious infractions such as sexual assault and other violent crimes. Often, the violations are not reported to police and rarely go to court.

The reasons are numerous. The boards can have nebulous rules. They are composed of college administrators, students and faculty who have little or no legal training. Many cases require judgment calls, and no one wants to ruin the academic life of a student because of one mistake.

Advertise with us

It would help if the U.S. Department of Education and the Department of Justice developed a template for how institutions of higher learning deal with student offenses, to create consistency among campuses. It should include the use of expert outside panels to investigate the most serious accusations.

Although college conduct boards have the authority to expel students or let them stay on campus, the gray area in between offers little protection to students who may be victimized, and often to the accused as well. These panels should be trained and required to adhere to consistent and established guidelines before they sit in judgment of students, and potentially their future.

Meet the Editorial Board.