Lost in the furor over the Senate committee report on the CIA’s use of brutal tactics on terror suspects is trouble of a different sort. Americans can add torture to immigration, health care, minimum wage and other issues over which Congress breaks hopelessly along party lines.

As seen in the competing realities described by Democrats and Republicans on the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, the dysfunction on Capitol Hill rolls on and now paralyzes federal lawmakers on the critical policy for dealing with overseas threats to American security.

The long-awaited report was produced by Democratic staff and released just before the party is about to relinquish control of the committee and the entire Senate to Republicans. The document contains more details than previous reports on CIA interrogation tactics to gain information from those who would harm the United States after the 9/​11 attacks.

Among the Democrats’ findings were: enhanced interrogation techniques such as waterboarding and sleep deprivation did not yield intelligence that led to operations against terrorists or blocked domestic attacks; treatment of detainees was more “physically harmful” than described by the CIA and included vomiting and convulsions due to the simulated drowning of waterboarding and ended in the death of one detainee from exposure; the CIA’s operation of secret “black site” prisons and severe interrogations was “deeply flawed,” with some personnel poorly trained and inexperienced; CIA officials gave inaccurate information to congressional leaders, the Bush White House and the press to avoid oversight; interrogators and jailers who used inhumane tactics not condoned by the CIA or Bush administration lawyers were rarely disciplined or reprimanded.

Advertise with us

The Republican members of the committee, who chose not to take part in the study, nevertheless issued a minority report which said: Although Democratic staff members reviewed 6 million pages of CIA documents, they did not conduct interviews, particularly with CIA officials, which led to “significant analytical and factual errors”; the CIA’s detention program “saved lives and played a vital role in weakening” al-Qaida’s terrorist network; while the staff report accuses the CIA of illegal torture, the agency consulted with the Justice Department about the harsh methods used.

Also critical of the Democrats’ conclusion, three former CIA directors said Wednesday in a Wall Street Journal commentary, “In no way would we claim that we did everything perfectly; far from it in the emergency and often-chaotic circumstances we confronted in the immediate aftermath of 9/​11.” Nonetheless, they said the report failed to acknowledge the feverish context in which the interrogations occurred — 3,000 American lives had just been lost, al-Qaida was suspected of planning a new attack, Osama bin Laden had met with Pakistani nuclear experts and information had indicated that nuclear weapons might be smuggled into New York City.

Despite the hard partisan lines drawn on the torture report, there were notable exceptions. Sen. Susan Collins of Maine, a Republican on the committee, said, “This inhumane and brutal treatment never should have occurred.’’ She signed on, however, to neither the Democratic nor the Republican report. Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., who was a U.S. pilot tortured in the Vietnam War, continued his general condemnation of brutal interrogations and applauded release of the report. He is not a member of the intelligence committee.

None of this, though, will have the same impact as a bipartisan committee conclusion with findings of fact on what occurred and recommendations for future policy. Americans want the truth, but today they don’t know what the truth is. What’s more, nothing is likely to result from the Democrats’ study — President Barack Obama welcomed the report while praising the “agonizing choices about how to pursue al-Qaida”; his Justice Department said it will not reopen a criminal investigation into the CIA’s treatment of detainees; no further action will come from a Republican Congress.

Yet treatment of enemies that approaches torture still gnaws at the American conscience, contradicts the nation’s values and potentially harms U.S. citizens overseas. Democrats and Republicans could have produced a single, factual report on this troubling matter that would have had all the weight and influence of the federal legislature. Instead, their fractured result smolders in the ashes of partisanship and spreads more noxious fumes of rancor.

Meet the Editorial Board.