Just in time for winter, Councilwoman Darlene Harris wants Pittsburgh dog owners to be mindful of their pets in harsh weather.

While her heart is in the right place, her bills on the outdoor treatment of dogs are loaded with so many stipulations that her concern could be ignored by pet owners and her proposals rendered unenforceable.

One bill governs the outdoor tethering of dogs and specifies that it not be done for longer than it takes an owner “to complete a temporary task.” The proposal says that any chain used must be at least 10 feet long and no thicker than one-eighth of an inch; that the dog have access to water, food and shade or shelter; and that the dog be outside for no more than 30 minutes when temperatures are below 32 degrees or above 90.

Mrs. Harris’ other bill would set building specifications for dog houses. They must have a solid, moisture-proof floor raised 3 inches above the ground. The roof must extend 8 inches over the doorway to keep out rain. The house must fit the size of the animal, with its depth the dog’s length plus 12 inches, its width the dog’s length plus 18 inches and its height the dog’s height plus 3 to 9 inches. The bill also requires the dog house to have “suitable bedding material consisting of straw, cedar shavings or the equivalent” and bars materials that retain moisture.

Advertise with us

Owners found violating the law could be convicted of a summary offense and subject to a $500 fine.

These are sensible guidelines on how to treat dogs, and they should be shared with all dog owners. But, as a matter of law, they would be complicated and difficult to enforce. Mrs. Harris’ desire for humane treatment of animals is commendable, but her call for an unwieldy ordinance is not.

Meet the Editorial Board.