According to an old, wise adage, “He who pays the piper calls the tune.” But when a private group pays a prosecutor, what discordant notes might be struck? It’s a good question for which an unusual law enforcement venture in Altoona, Blair County, has brought mixed answers.
As the Post-Gazette’s Rich Lord reported last Sunday, a group of prominent business leaders formed a nonprofit organization called Operation Our Town in 2007 to do something about a dismaying drug problem in the area. There wasn’t enough tax revenue to do the job.
Since then, the group has raised more than $2 million for drug prevention, education and, most problematically, enforcement. Operation Our Town sends six-figure sums every year to the Blair County district attorney’s office to help police and to cover the $52,126 salary (plus benefits) of an assistant district attorney specially hired to prosecute drug cases.
Credit the program for some encouraging results: 241 drug cases filed against 124 defendants last year. Credit the backers of Operation Our Town for good intentions, although they don’t dwell on the details. “I don’t know how [police] use informants or don’t use informants,” said Joseph Sheetz, treasurer of Operation Our Town. “I just know they need more money to complete investigations.”
But what they don’t know may be the problem. The Post-Gazette found Ryan Scott Eger, a heroin addict caught up in the program. He said he was recruited by a fellow addict turned informant to become a deliveryman for drugs. When busted, he said, he in turn became an informant and he could still use drugs and police paid $40 per buy.
If this weren’t disturbing enough, the practice may not even be strictly legal. Courts in California and Tennessee have rejected private groups funding prosecutions. At the very least, it’s bad public policy. Governments should pay their own way without inviting conflicts of interest.
While there’s no evidence the piper here has paid for a bad tune, the potential is always there. That’s why privately funded prosecutions, once common in America in the 1800s, were abandoned. Blair County should take heed. In drug dealing or in drug prosecuting, there’s no easy money.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.