The U.S. Supreme Court must decide if threats made on social media are protected as free speech under the First Amendment. The court should rule that, whether delivered in person, by phone, in a letter or digitally, a threat is still a threat.
The justices, who heard arguments this week, will decide whether to uphold the conviction of a Northampton County man who was found guilty of making threatening statements to his estranged wife and law enforcement officials on Facebook.
In 2011, Anthony Elonis was convicted of communicating illegal threats across state lines, via the Internet, which made those acts a federal crime. He was sentenced to 44 months in prison. Elonis argues that his postings were harmless, therapeutic venting. He says he was only mimicking the lyrics of rap artists.
But there is little ambiguity, or artistic expression, in Elonis’ postings. Not only did he send frightening messages, he promised to act on them. In one note to his wife, he wrote: “I’m not gonna rest until your body is a mess, soaked in blood and dying from all the little cuts.” After she was granted a personal protection order against him, Elonis advised: “Fold up your protective order and put it in your pocket. Is it thick enough to stop a bullet?”
It seems clear that Elonis intended to instill terror in her, even though some justices correctly observed that intent is hard to prove. The Supreme Court has held that “true threats” are not constitutionally protected. A “reasonable person” — the required legal standard — likely would feel truly threatened by his words, particularly after a nasty breakup.
During this week’s arguments, Justice Samuel Alito asserted that Elonis’ violent Facebook rants were credible threats. “This sounds like a road map for threatening your spouse and then getting away with it,” he said.
Elonis repeatedly issued particular — and graphic — threats against a particular person. In any form, there should be little debate about the power of his words.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.