Given all the legal challenges that have been brought against the Affordable Care Act, you’d think the law posed an imminent threat to Americans’ well-being. Surely, lawmakers and courts wouldn’t waste time on frivolous litigation.
You would, unfortunately, be wrong. The most recent lawsuit by House Speaker John Boehner against the health care law is only the latest attempt to wreck a program that has been, by any rational measure, a success. Never mind that the law has helped millions of Americans obtain health insurance at a reasonable cost to them and the nation. President Barack Obama’s opponents are bent on clawing back Obamacare, and poor and middle-class Americans’ health coverage along with it.
Mr. Boehner’s suit will likely be thrown out because of a lack of legal standing. He and other Republicans seek to win favor with conservative voters and interest groups rather than fix the law. But one case to be heard by the Supreme Court has a distinct chance of succeeding. If it does, it would gut the health insurance subsidies available to low- and middle-income Americans.
The lawsuit hinges on a section of the health care law that says federal subsidies will be available to people who buy insurance through “an exchange established by the state.” The plaintiffs say that only people living in states that set up their own insurance exchanges are eligible for subsidies. Most states are relying on exchanges set up for them by the federal government.
That the high court agreed to hear the case suggests that its conservative majority has a political interest in overturning the subsidies. That would spell disaster for much of the progress made by Obamacare — and to what end?
Health care subsidies have proved to be sound policy. A healthy work force benefits everyone, and the government has an interest in making sure as many Americans as possible can get insured. Until Obamacare critics have a better solution, they need to put their attacks on it to rest.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.