For good or ill, football players are seen as role models by many of the nation’s youth. In the case of Ray Rice, the former Baltimore Ravens running back, his likely return to the National Football League is all for the worse.

On Friday, an arbitrator overturned his indefinite suspension after the airing of a shocking video showing him knocking unconscious his then-fiancee, now his wife, in a hotel elevator. With the graphic evidence for all to see, Mr. Rice became the face of domestic violence. The NFL, confronted with its own laxity, increased the original penalty of a two-game suspension and a $500,000 fine.

It seemed a reasonable step at the time, an acknowledgement that the league — given its wider societal responsibility to set a good example — was finally going to get tough about domestic violence, even if it didn’t get the call right the first time. But the arbitrator, Barbara S. Jones, a former district court judge, threw a flag on that play.

Ms. Jones accepted the player’s argument that he was being penalized twice for the same incident. She found that Mr. Rice had not misled Commissioner Roger Goodell about the violent nature of the incident. “That the league did not realize the severity of the conduct without a visual record also speaks to their admitted failure in the past to sanction this type of conduct more severely,” she wrote. So much for the idea that a picture is worth a thousand words.

Advertise with us

This is vindication for the player only in a narrow legal sense. It leaves the league with the prospect of having someone who behaved brutally toward a domestic partner as the recipient of fan adulation. Perhaps no team will have him back, but that may be too much to hope.

What can be hoped is that this will propel the NFL to have strict rules and an unforgiving attitude toward domestic violence going forward, so that no player can claim double jeopardy. The NFL needs to become an institution that can be admired by fans young and old.

Meet the Editorial Board.