Pennsylvania officials wasted no time last week in putting the CEOs of Highmark and UPMC on notice that their latest sparring match was hitting customers below the belt.
In a letter sent Wednesday, the state’s insurance commissioner, attorney general and health secretary ordered Highmark insurance to suspend its previously announced termination of 700 UPMC doctors. They told UPMC to clarify or retract statements that Highmark’s Medicare Advantage programs would exclude UPMC facilities and doctors next year.
Credit the state for quick intervention, but, long term, it’s going to take more than a letter to make the combatants stop.
State officials issued the orders so they could mediate, as provided by the consent decree worked out between the health care giants and the state in July. Although Highmark and UPMC claimed their moves were meant to clarify what their elderly customers can expect on Jan. 1, when most other Highmark customers will no longer have routine in-network access to UPMC, that’s not how the state saw it. The letter said the actions of both “created additional uncertainty and confusion for the senior population.”
Even at this late date, too many of the decisions and too much of the marketing by Highmark and UPMC seem calculated to play on the fears of health care customers. By stepping in quickly, state officials sought to head off panic by Medicare customers who have only until Dec. 7 to choose a plan and enroll for next year.
Yet confusion still reigns for many patients caught in the middle of Highmark and UPMC, and not all of them are of Medicare age. While nothing will stop the split that’s coming between the health care competitors in 2015, the state needs to block the next round of moves that stir doubts about what a person’s insurance will and will not deliver.
That would take a meeting in Harrisburg with Highmark and UPMC called by Gov. Tom Corbett. A pointed, face-to-face sit-down is far more preferable to a letter after the fact. When you’re talking about people’s health care, better to be proactive than reactive.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.