Wise U.S. policy toward a complex Russia may be found only by delving deeper into the issue, as if it were a souvenir set of matryoshka nesting dolls.
The United States sprang forward in defense of the integrity of Ukraine as Russia clamped down on its bordering eastern region, including Crimea and the now claimed as sovereign Donetsk and Luhansk People’s Republics. America imposed economic and political sanctions on Russia and put pressure on its European partners to do likewise. Poisoned relations reached a crescendo at the just-completed G-20 summit in Brisbane, Australia, where leaders of Australia, Canada, the United Kingdom and the United States took turns verbally beating up Russian President Vladimir V. Putin until he reportedly went home early.
Whether this policy makes sense may be another question. Ukraine is not a member of either NATO or the European Union. Russia has important trading relationships with various European countries, including those which depend on it for natural gas. In spite of expressions of concern by several countries neighboring Russia, it is extremely unlikely that Russia would mess with NATO members Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Norway or Poland.
In the meantime, Russia is both scaling back previous fruitful areas of cooperation with the United States, including two decades of cooperation in securing nuclear materials inside Russia, and expanding its political and economic ties to China, including some big natural gas deals that will permit it to cut off Western Europe at less cost to itself. Russia is also making life more difficult for U.S. companies working in Russia. It remains helpful in United Nations Security Council talks with Iran on that country’s nuclear program, improving its own relations with Iran in the process.
It is hard to see any gain for the United States in continuing hostile relations with Russia, particularly if the problems are based primarily on issues far from home, in Russia’s backyard — issues that the Ukrainians, Russians and other Europeans should be working out among themselves.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.