It is natural to rejoice in the news that Philadelphia 10-year-old Sarah Murnaghan received a desperately needed lung transplant last week after rules that cover organ procurement and allocation were bent to address her medical need.

Sarah faces a complicated recovery with widespread public support for the accommodation that was made to save her. There is potential for even greater good to result from her case, but not if such decisions can too easily be taken away from medical professionals and handed off to judges instead.

Sarah and another young cystic fibrosis patient were the beneficiaries after the Murnaghan family undertook an intense media and legal fight, calling attention to the so-called Under 12 rule of the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network. The organization, which oversees the national organ distribution system, required that any lungs from adult donors first be offered to adult patients on waiting lists before any patient under 12 could be considered. It didn't matter if the children were far sicker than the adults.

A federal judge circumvented the rule and ordered Sarah and the other child onto the adult list because of their urgent need. The network, which rightly should be making those calls, originally criticized the judge's decision. However, the organization then took the long view. It decided to temporarily ease the rules applied to children for a year while the issue is studied carefully.

Advertise with us

This was an important change.

First of all, the transplant rules must be uniformly followed and not subject to a judge's ruling or a family's ability to wage a public campaign. Second, given the ever-improving practice of transplanting organs, periodic re-evaluation of what works best for patients is vital.

A systemic review should reassure patients that the rules are in sync with the latest medical technology. If potential recipients are excluded from transplantation based on outdated regulations, patients and the public could lose faith that the system is fair, which could hurt organ donation.

As it is, although 90 percent of Pennsylvanians support organ donation in theory, only 45.6 percent of those with drivers' licenses are registered to donate, a figure far lower than exists in some other states. A newly launched Donate Life Pennsylvania campaign aims to increase the number of registered organ donors.

That would be the best possible outcome.