I was ensconced in the apartment of friends on the Lower East Side of Manhattan the night of the last presidential debate when the Liar-in-Chief stated that New York City was “dying,” “ a ghost town.”
We looked at each other with that incredulous expression that many of us have been used to contorting our faces into for almost four years, expressions that are familiar to the parents of children who lie incorrigibly about things that are so easy to disprove.
Below the high-rise apartment, the streets were busy with pedestrians and vehicles. The night before, a Peruvian restaurant’s outside shelter in Queens was almost filled with diners as we ate. The sidewalk traffic was robust, as was all traffic during my entire stay.
Besides Queens, we walked through the Lower East Side and Chinatown, visited Brooklyn and Harlem, keeping our masks up as we walked because it would have been impossible to veer away from the people on the streets.
The mask wearing that I witnessed among New Yorkers was remarkably compliant.
The weather was mild enough that we could leave all the windows and the balcony door open in the apartment, where, after the debate, we discussed the resilience and spirit of the nation’s largest and most diverse city. We also discussed the pathological lying of the juvenile man who holds the highest public office in our country.
Saying that New York is a ghost town was not the most egregious lie he has told, nor is it the most troubling. But the casualness with which he lies and exaggerates is his most troubling collective body of work. It indicates a disorder that seems uncontrollable, since in these instances, it would be so much easier not to come up with a whopper.
I’m reminded of lyrics in the song by Delbert McClinton, “Lie No Better”:
If you can’t lie no better than that
You might as well tell the truth
New York City’s retail, hospitality and cultural entities are hurting, like in all cities. Surely traffic is down. Chinatown, the area we always visit when I spend a few days in late October in New York, is not nearly as bustling as usual.
But the ghost town reference played right into the hands of Stephen Colbert, who, on his TV talk show that night, used the proximity to Halloween for a taunt: “Mr. President, when you come to New York, those aren’t ghosts on the street. Those are people BOO-ing you.”
By now, no lie, big or small, from the most disturbed and disturbing occupant of the White House should shock us. And if the unprecedented turnout in early voting is a sign, these lies will soon be consigned to an outlier life at Mar-a-Lago or, if justice finally plays out, in prison.
In the meantime, New York City is hanging in there, like most of the country, abiding.
The vendors in Chinatown are wearing masks like responsible adults, and the country’s most densely populated city is holding the line on the coronavirus, compared to wide-open, lightly populated places like North Dakota.
Thinking back on April and May, when refrigerator trucks were used to store overflow bodies of COVID-19 fatalities in New York City, I am struck by how well the city seems to be doing now.
My friends worry about the winter and how this latest nationwide swell might affect their beloved metropolis, as I worry about my beloved smaller one.
But I left New York feeling somewhat buoyed. I credit, in part, the ridiculously long lines that formed on the first day of early voting on Saturday. Long lines are troubling, especially in states where the suppression of the votes of Black citizens is historic. Lines in such states, including Georgia, were egregiously long. Yet voters stuck it out for eight, nine hours, to do their patriotic duty.
In Brooklyn, Barclays Center — home of the Brooklyn Nets and New York Islanders — was the largest site of early voting, and lines wrapped around it like tape around a fragile package. That was on the first day of early voting. People wore backpacks carrying food and water. Some opened folding chairs and sat in line, waiting.
One elderly Black man told a television interviewer that he was prepared for the long haul, however long he had to wait, because “my people marched for this right.” He was cheerful. Meanwhile, many elders in line were allowed to go ahead, and there appeared to be no pushback from other voters. One young voter had just turned 18 and expressed his excitement at having a voice. His parents were with him, beaming, you could tell, even behind their masks.
Without knowing for whom the majority of people in line would be voting, I suspected that the huge bulk were drawn to their civic duty by the energy of people who respond to emergencies, like those people on the beach who were shown in a viral video forming a human chain out into the water to rescue a floundering swimmer.
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.