It is a remarkable thing when an entire country changes its mind. Andrew Jackson, once almost universally admired as a personification of refreshing democratic values, now is considered a prosecutor of genocide. Ulysses Grant, once portrayed as a shiftless drunk and political dunce, is a symbol of generosity and prudence.

Woodrow Wilson, once hailed as the idealist of his age, is considered a racist. Dwight Eisenhower, once disparaged as a presidential mediocrity principally interested in his putting game, is remembered for putting America on a strong footing for the coming decade of the 1960s.

But the most remarkable transformation of the modern age may involve a president in office a mere 17 months and the controversial step he took at the end of his first month.

An infamous Sunday

That decision arguably cost Gerald Ford his presidency but might have helped the country recover after two years of Watergate-related strife.

Advertise with us

This Sunday is the 50th anniversary of a Sunday that began in infamy with Mr. Ford’s pardon of Richard Nixon.

The general reaction was summed up by Washington Post reporter Carl Bernstein in a call to his reporting colleague Bob Woodward: “The son of a bitch pardoned the son of a bitch.”

The Ford approval rating, at 71% at the end of his first week in office in the middle of August, fell to 60% just after the pardon in September, then to 50% by month’s end — en route to 37% in the following January, according to the Gallup Poll.

Seven years later, the country was evenly divided, with 46% supporting the pardon and 46% opposing it. By 1986, 39% still opposed the pardon, but a majority (54%) approved.

Running against Ford in 1976, Jimmy Carter criticized the pardon, saying he would not have pardoned President Nixon “until after the trial had been completed in order to let all the facts relating to his crimes be known.”

Advertise with us

Six months later, he began his Inaugural Address with this sentence, which didn’t mention the pardon but spoke of the result Mr. Ford hoped it would provide: “For myself and for our nation, I want to thank my predecessor for all he has done to heal our land.”

Sen. Edward M. Kennedy of Massachusetts immediately branded the pardon “the culmination of the Watergate cover-up.” A quarter-century later, the committee awarding the John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum’s Profiles in Courage Award received a high school student’s essay arguing Mr. Ford was an exemplar of political courage.

Two committee members, David Burke, the former president of CBS News, and David McCullough, the historian whose biographies of John Adams and Harry Truman single-handedly changed the nation’s view of them both, said the student was on to something.

Paul Kirk, former chairman of the Democratic National Committee and later a senator, resisted. Sen. Kennedy was hesitant but finally came around. Mr. Ford was presented with the award in 2001.

‘I finally was okay with it, and had a conversation with President Ford who said that this was redemption and satisfaction,” said Mr. Kirk. “I saw his pride in vindication.”

Advertise with us

The president’s explanation

Mr. Ford wrote in his autobiography that the Nixon pardon “wasn’t motivated primarily by sympathy for his plight or by concern over the state of his health.” It was “the state of the country’s health at home and around the world that worried me.”

The country at first didn’t buy his argument. “If Ford can be faulted, it’s how it was done, and how it was packaged,” said Richard Norton Smith, the author of the 2023 biography of Mr. Ford, “An Ordinary Man.”

“Ford felt twinges of sympathy for Nixon,” he said. “He believed Nixon’s health, both physical and mental, was impaired. He thought there was only one way to get Nixon off his daily schedule and, critically important, to change the story in the media.”

Ken Khachigian, a longtime Nixon aide, said Mr. Ford succeeded in that goal. “The wailing about the pardon would last only so long, but, while [Nixon critics still] had Nixon to kick around, it was as a long distance appetizer, not an on-site feast.”

John Robert Greene, one of the first scholars to examine Ford’s papers for his 1995 book “The Presidency of Gerald R. Ford,” thinks the pardon “was more about getting rid of the tapes and papers that still filled the White House.”

Advertise with us

“But most important,” he said, “every press conference since he became president was consumed by questions about Nixon. It was beating at him. He didn’t think he could do anything as president unless he pulled the Band-Aid off the wound and pardoned him.”

Then there is Timothy Naftali, the first director of the federal Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum, who felt the pardon was premature. “But I respect Ford and what he tried to achieve,” he said. “It would have been useful for the public to see a criminal indictment, though I know enough about the story to understand that it was unlikely.”

Grace and mercy

In an interview my friend Ken Gormley conducted, Ford’s son Steve recalled his father explaining that pardoning Nixon was an act of “grace and mercy.”

The grace and mercy eventually reached Bob Woodward, on the other end of the “son of a bitch” phone call from Carl Bernstein. In a July 2014 Washington Post panel, he called the pardon “an act of courage.” The country had come around.

David Shribman, executive editor emeritus of the Post-Gazette and scholar in residence at Carnegie Mellon University, was a member of the Kennedy Library’s Profiles in Courage selection committee, but was not in the group when the award was given to Mr. Ford.