Pres­i­dent Don­ald Trump hasn’t called on his pres­i­den­tial pre­de­ces­sors to help him ad­dress the cor­o­navi­rus threat. In­stead, two of them made the call them­selves in re­cent days — not to the White House but to the Amer­i­can peo­ple.

“Let us re­mem­ber how small our dif­fer­ences are in the face of this shared threat,” for­mer Pres­i­dent George W. Bush said in a three-minute video that was part of a “Call to Unite” on­line of­fen­sive of na­tional up­lift and na­tional pur­pose. “In the fi­nal anal­y­sis, we are not par­ti­san com­bat­ants. We are hu­man be­ings, equally vul­ner­a­ble and equally won­der­ful in the sight of God. We rise or fall to­gether and we are de­ter­mined to rise. God bless you all.”

He was not alone. Pres­i­dent Bill Clin­ton also had some words for the na­tion he led two de­cades ago. “We need each other, and we do bet­ter when we work to­gether,” he said. “That’s never been more clear to me as I have seen the cour­age and dig­nity of the first re­spond­ers, the health care work­ers, all the peo­ple who are help­ing them to pro­vide our food, our trans­por­ta­tion, our ba­sic ser­vices to the other es­sen­tial work­ers.”

Mr. Trump has been more pu­gi­list than part­ner with his pre­de­ces­sors, re­peat­edly spurn­ing their ad­vice.

Advertise with us

“I don’t think I’m go­ing to learn much,” Mr. Trump said when he was asked whether he might con­sult with his White House pre­de­ces­sors as the cor­o­navi­rus threat deep­ened. “I guess you could say that there’s prob­a­bly a nat­u­ral in­cli­na­tion not to call.”

And yet in mod­ern Amer­i­can his­tory pres­i­dents have had a nat­u­ral in­cli­na­tion to make that call.

In the mid­dle of the 1962 Cuban mis­sile cri­sis, when the world was clos­est to nu­clear war­fare, Pres­i­dent John F. Ken­nedy made three im­por­tant phone calls: one to Her­bert Hoover, a Re­pub­li­can his father cam­paigned against in the 1932 elec­tion; a sec­ond to Harry Tru­man, who thought Ken­nedy was cal­low and spine­less; and the third to Dwight D. Ei­sen­hower, whom Ken­nedy had pil­lo­ried in his 1960 cam­paign for cre­at­ing a mis­sile gap and for fail­ing to pre­pare the na­tion for its dan­ger­ous fu­ture.

Much the way Justin Trudeau called on for­mer Prime Min­is­ter Joe Clark ear­lier this year to help Can­ada win a ro­tat­ing Se­cu­rity Coun­cil seat, mod­ern Amer­i­can pres­i­dents of­ten have called on their pre­de­ces­sors for as­sis­tance — and sup­port.

“The ‘ex-pres­i­dents club’ is an amaz­ing re­source for a cur­rent pres­i­dent,” said Rice Univer­sity his­to­rian Douglas Brin­kley, who has writ­ten on the two Pres­i­dent Roosevelts and President Ken­nedy. “The ‘exes’ know how to deal with cri­sis in real time and can of­fer sage wis­dom. Pres­i­dent Trump could ben­e­fit from that.”

Advertise with us

If you have any doubt about the value of two pres­i­dents ex­am­in­ing a dif­fi­cult sit­u­a­tion, in­vest lit­tle more than two min­utes study­ing this ex­change be­tween Ken­nedy and Ei­sen­hower in Oc­to­ber 1962.

Ken­nedy opened by in­form­ing Ei­sen­hower he was go­ing to im­pose a block­ade — he would even­tu­ally use the less mar­tial term “quar­an­tine” — on Cuba.

“Well, I thank you for tell­ing me,” Ei­sen­hower said, add­ing “I think you’re re­ally mak­ing the only move you can.”

Ken­nedy in­ter­jected: “I don’t know, we may get into the in­va­sion busi­ness be­fore many days are out.”

The two then dis­cussed Ni­kita Khrushchev’s mo­tives in in­stall­ing mis­siles 90 miles from Flor­ida. Ken­nedy said he be­lieved it was part of a chess game over Ber­lin, then a Cold War flash­point. Ei­sen­hower didn’t agree.

Advertise with us

“I just don’t go along with that think­ing,” he said, ex­plain­ing, “I don’t be­lieve they re­late one sit­u­a­tion with an­other.”

Then Ken­nedy asked the vi­tal ques­tion: “Gen­eral, what about if the So­viet Union, uh, Khrushchev, an­nounces to­mor­row, which I think he will, that if we at­tack Cuba that it’s go­ing to be nu­clear war? And what’s your judg­ment as to the chances they’ll fire these things [nu­clear weap­ons] off if we in­vade Cuba?”

Ei­sen­hower’s re­ply? “Oh, I don’t be­lieve that they will.”

Lyn­don John­son en­listed Tru­man in his 1965 fight to win pas­sage of Med­i­care — and then in­vited him to the pres­i­den­tial sign­ing cer­e­mony. Ron­ald Rea­gan sent Pres­i­dents Jimmy Carter, Ger­ald Ford and Rich­ard Nixon to the fu­neral of Egypt’s as­sas­si­nated Pres­i­dent An­war el-Sa­dat in 1981. George H.W. Bush con­sulted with Mr. Carter on cri­ses in Pan­ama and Nic­ara­gua. Mr. Clin­ton re­peat­edly con­sulted with Nixon on Rus­sia and post-Cold War mat­ters. George W. Bush leaned on Mr. Clin­ton in the ef­fort to bat­tle AIDS and on his father, George H.W. Bush, and Mr. Clin­ton in the ef­fort to re­build af­ter Hur­ri­cane Kat­rina.

Amid his im­peach­ment trial and then the 2020 cor­o­navi­rus cri­sis, Mr. Trump made no such phone calls to for­mer pres­i­dents, though his four liv­ing po­ten­tial White House kitchen cab­i­net members might of­fer un­usual per­spec­tive: Mr. Carter, who fought to erad­i­cate guinea worms and river blind­ness; Mr. Clin­ton, who also faced and de­feated a par­ti­san ef­fort to re­move him from im­peach­ment; the younger Mr. Bush, who faced an in­va­sion from abroad of a dif­fer­ent but just as chill­ing qual­ity; and Barack Obama, who bat­tled an Ebola ep­i­demic.

Advertise with us

Even so, Mr. Clin­ton had some un­so­lic­ited ad­vice for Mr. Trump as the im­peach­ment drama un­folded. “Look, you got hired to do a job,” Mr. Clin­ton told CNN. “You don’t get the days back you blow off. Every day’s an op­por­tu­nity to make some­thing good hap­pen.”

Pres­i­den­tial re­la­tion­ships, to be sure, of­ten are fraught. Tru­man and Ei­sen­hower were never close. Frank­lin Roosevelt didn’t con­sult with Hoover, who was an ar­dent critic of FDR’s New Deal. Abra­ham Lin­coln was convinced that James Buchanan helped cre­ate the Civil War; the only known in­ter­change be­tween the two of them in the Lin­coln pres­i­dency came in the form of an Oct. 21, 1861, let­ter, now bur­ied in the Li­brary of Con­gress, in which the 15th pres­i­dent asked of the 16th (whom he ad­dressed as “My dear sir”) to re­turn to him “some seven or eight vol­umes” — books he in­ad­ver­tently left in the White House li­brary.

But for most of them, the pres­i­dency is what Tho­mas Jef­fer­son, who had a late-life in­ti­mate cor­re­spon­dence with his pre­de­ces­sor, John Adams, called a “glo­ri­ous bur­den” — one that only 44 men have shared in more than two cen­tu­ries.

“It is more than a mere cour­tesy for sit­ting pres­i­dents to con­sult with their pre­de­ces­sors,” said Mr. Brin­kley. “It is a great op­por­tu­nity for them, and you have to won­der why Pres­i­dent Trump wouldn’t want to use the pres­i­dents to help heal the na­tion.”

David M. Shrib­man is a for­mer and now emer­i­tus ex­ec­u­tive ed­i­tor of the Post-Ga­zette and a na­tion­ally syn­di­cated col­um­nist. He is a vis­it­ing pro­fes­sor at McGill Univer­sity in Mon­treal (dshrib­man@post-ga­zette.com).