In an age of confusion, in an era of precision, at a time of cultural and political contention, what are we to make of precise poll data that reflect nothing short of confusion and contention?
Are the polls confused, or is it simply that the interpreters of those public-sentiment gauges are confused? Do these polls reflect, or contribute to, the confusion and contention?
Whatever the answers, the curious fact remains that the latest Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll shows two seemingly contradictory upticks — one for the Democrats’ prospects in November’s midterm congressional elections, one for President Donald J. Trump’s approval.
Maybe the confusion — maybe all the contradictions we see in our politics — are the zeitgeist of the era. This is, after all, a time when the Republicans are the populists (and, on the issue of Mr. Trump’s steel and aluminum tariffs, the unlikely allies of the labor unions) and at a time when the Democrats are the elitists (and the party most appealing to many of the plutocrats who occupy the commanding heights of the most vibrant parts of the economy).
This confusion and these contradictions have their analogue in an important constitutional provision that may help explain the unease so many feel about the current political age. (More on this in a moment.) They also may provide hints as to why Mr. Trump is regarded with disdain by the Democrats who otherwise since 1896 — with diversions during the Theodore Roosevelt years and to a lesser degree in the Ronald Reagan years — have had the ears, the hearts and the votes of populists.
Indeed, the most profound change may be among the Republicans. Not so long ago, Sen. Sherrod Brown, the Democrat from Ohio, was quoted as saying that “the Republican establishment has captured the government,” adding, “When it comes to what they’re really trying to do every day, it’s the bidding of the billionaire Republican establishment — of Wall Street, of the drug companies, of the gun lobby.”
Not so fast. Maybe the drug companies, maybe the gun lobby, but surely not the Republican establishment. It is aghast at what the Trump administration is doing, especially on trade. Perhaps the only group as disenchanted with the Trump administration, and with Mr. Trump himself, as Mr. Brown may be the Republican establishment. Its members are watching their power eroding in slow motion, and if Mr. Trump wins a second term, historians may date the end of the modern Republican Party to his nomination in Cleveland nearly two years ago.
Moreover — here the true historical heresies begin — maybe it is Theodore Roosevelt and Reagan, and not Herbert Hoover and Calvin Coolidge, who represent the real past and future of the GOP. Maybe — to continue the heretic thinking — our conceptions are upside down, or at a minimum require a fresh look. Perhaps it is Franklin Roosevelt (and his many lineal Democratic descendants) who are the historical aberrations.
This debate can go on forever. Because the one lesson of American history is that the past is always changing, the settled is always being revised, the reviled are sometimes being rehabilitated.
In a book that itself upset all the conventional views — “The Hidden-Hand Presidency” began the long project of rehabilitating historians’ views of Dwight Eisenhower, a process that continued this month with two new biographies — the Princeton scholar Fred I. Greenstein wrote this consensus-shattering passage about the Constitution, so often regarded with hushed reverence:
“One of the most profound sources of discontent with the performance of presidents was built into the job of chief executive in 1787 by the framers of the Constitution. The American president is asked to perform two roles that in most democracies are assigned to separate individuals. He must serve both as chief of state and as the nation’s highest political executive. The roles seem almost designed to collide.”
Mr. Greenstein argued that as the head of the executive branch, the president, like a British prime minister, has “intrinsically divisive responsibilities,” with the attendant risk of forfeiting “his broad acceptance as leader of the entire nation.” But as chief of state, the president, like constitutional monarchs, “is a symbol of unity,” a figure “expected by Americans to represent the entire nation.”
It is in that latter role that Mr. Trump is least comfortable, and it is in that role — “symbol of unity” — that he provides the least comfort to the nation, even to many Republicans whose loyalty to party and presidency has been, until now, unquestioned.
“For the most part, the presidency changes the president into a better man,” said Craig Shirley, a veteran of several GOP presidential campaigns and the author of four volumes on Mr. Reagan. “When presidents assume office, they often assume a new humility and faith.”
The principal example, as of so much of the presidency, is Abraham Lincoln, who said the only answers he could find were in devout contemplation. “I have been driven many times upon by knees by the overwhelming conviction that I had no where else to go,” he said. “My own wisdom and that of all about me seemed insufficient.”
Much of this is enough to make us rethink the conventional view of the presidency — at a time when Mr. Trump is in (conscious and deliberate) violation of many of the customs of the presidency. He does not, for example, measure his words; they spill into Twitter at all hours. He has no respect for the conventions of the office; where previous presidents (Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon) harbored doubts about institutions such as the State Department and FBI, Mr. Trump is distrustful of them.
“We like to think there’s an act of magic that occurs when someone puts his hand on the Bible for that oath of office,” said Richard Norton Smith, who has been director of the Hoover, Eisenhower, Gerald Ford and Reagan presidential libraries, is the author of a Hoover biography and is at work on a Ford biography. “We think that at that moment he grows.”
Not always. Where John F. Kennedy, George W. Bush and Barack Obama were works in progress in the White House, Eisenhower, Lyndon Johnson, George H.W. Bush and Mr. Trump entered the White House as finished products. The current president is unchanging even as — more than perhaps any of them, with the exception of Johnson, whose embrace of civil rights opened the South to the Republicans — he is changing American politics.
David M. Shribman is executive editor of the Post-Gazette (dshribman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1890).



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.