Suppose a soft drink company, remembering that Coke once contained a tiny bit of cocaine, enough to have some effect, decided to boost its sales by secretly adding a tiny bit of cocaine to its bestselling drink.
A little extra stimulation would be an effective way “to encourage consumer loyalty,” as the company’s internal documents would undoubtedly put it, because such companies don’t like to say what they’re really doing. They could hide the drug, as the recipe would be a protected trade secret.
I’m fairly sure that if anyone had qualms, someone would explain to him that just a little bit wouldn’t harm anyone, and if that person pointed out that children would be drinking it, too, the same someone would explain to him that just a little bit wouldn’t harm children either. It is unlikely anyone would suggest that in that case, they should list the ingredients on the label so customers knew what they were getting.
The company would eventually get caught, of course, but not until they’d made a lot of money adding an addictive substance. They’d have made the company much bigger. From a business point of view, the risk had been worth the profits. If they get sued, they can absorb the loss.
Americans would be enraged. No one likes to be secretly manipulated in making what they thought was a free choice. No one wants to buy one thing they want only to find out later it was a thing they didn’t want. No one tolerates being tricked.
Nearly everyone would recognize that sneaking in an addictive substance to a normal drink violated the customer’s personal integrity and free will. And it was false advertising (lying) to boot, because the company had let people think they were getting the same old thing when they weren’t.
Cheering lawsuits
That is what Meta and YouTube (owned by Google) were just found to have done in one cheering lawsuit, and Meta found to have done in another. The companies denied that they had failed in any way.
The first had been brought by a young woman identified as K.G.M. Her lawyer, reported The New York Times, “presented the jury internal company documents from Meta and YouTube that showed tech executives knew of and discussed the negative effects of their products on children. Mr. Lanier argued that features like infinite scroll, algorithmic recommendations and autoplay videos were designed to entice and hook young users to compulsively engage with the platforms.”
K.G.M. claimed that these features “led to anxiety and depression” as well as “body dysmorphia and thoughts of self harm.” The jury agreed and awarded her $4.8 million from Meta and $1.2 million from YouTube.
The second lawsuit had been brought by New Mexico’s Attorney General Raúl Torrez. “The company’s lax safety protocols allowed sexual predators to contact minors,” the Times reported. Torrez said that Meta chose “to put profits over kids’ safety. Meta executives knew their products harmed children, disregarded warnings from their own employees and lied to the public about what they knew.” The jury agreed and awarded $325 million in damages against Meta.
All these companies had incentives to do the equivalent of adding a tiny bit of cocaine to the drink. They make money, vast amounts of money, keeping users on the site. They increase shareholder value. Not to do that would require an idea of moral limits or the common good they do not seem to have.
A shared morality
Despite America’s great diversity, fortunately, we have a mostly shared baseline morality to some (always inadequate) degree observed, which would be seen if a soft drinks company acted as I described. People are not things to be tricked and manipulated.
Meta, Google and others violated it. The suits are hopeful signs that people are beginning to see their techniques as violations.
Not everyone, of course. Some people commenting on The New York Times story about K.G.M.’s suit offered versions of “just don’t do it” and wrote as if doing that were as easy for children and young people as they claimed it was for themselves. Companies like Meta could do whatever they wanted because the children were responsible for their response.
Only someone who doesn’t care if children come to harm or wants to exploit them, meaning a barbarian, believes that. As a nation, we do not believe that. We hold that they must be protected, and among the forces from which they must be protected are predatory adults, including predatory businesses.
We don’t say to them, “Just don’t do it.” They have to be so old to drink and so old to have sex. Someone who gives or sells alcohol to underage kids commits a crime. Someone who has sex with an underage kid commits a crime. Pornographic sites are supposed to keep out children under 18.
Protecting children
America agrees that children can’t completely protect themselves, especially from professional manipulators. How else could you describe companies who design their products to effectively addict users, including children, because time on their site is money in their pocket? And who do so knowing how easily children can be damaged?
Mark Zuckerberg and his peers are barbarians. (Remember how many of them were together on Jan. 20 of last year.) They don’t care for the common good but for their bottom line. How encouraging it is that so many people recognize that and some courts agree.
David Mills’s previous column was “Cesar Chavez was a hero in public and a very bad man in private.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.