The columnists, contributing writers and others this week will be commenting on Donald Trump’s first year, on the anniversary week of his second inauguration.

It was a better time when people asked presidents questions about their underwear. Older readers will remember when in 1992 a young woman on an MTV show asked then-candidate Bill Clinton, “Boxers or briefs?” which he answered.

The right criticized him for vulgarizing the presidency and lowering the tone of public discourse. His critics pointed to the power of the presidency to shape public manners and blamed Clinton for not taking seriously his responsibility to set an example.

That was a conservative insight based on understanding the fragility of public order and how much what we say sustains it or breaks it down. It also recognized that the president served not just as the executive of a governmental structure but as a model who set standards.

Advertise with us

That seems to be the natural, and I think unfortunate, effect of so much power focused in one person. Even people who dislike a president feel his influence. The way he lives and speaks gives permission for the breaking of rules or encouragement to follow them.

The right then disliked Clinton’s minor offense against the dignity of the presidency he sought. The right 33 years later now happily follows the most publicly vulgar man in presidential history.

Shifting the window

The movement that once tut-tutted Clinton’s mention of his unmentionables now cheers Trump’s coarseness and cruelty. They accuse people who object to his language of being upset by “mean tweets” and of “pearl-clutching.”

It’s just the way he is, they say, no big deal. They say it’s a rhetorical technique, a way of getting what he wants. Both of those are true, but they’re not points in Trump’s favor.

As I’ve written before, I can understand why, in our binary political system and with disagreements on crucial issues so deep, conservatives continue to support Donald Trump. But they are responsible for maintaining conservative principles and for resisting the aspects of Trump’s policies and performance to which they object.

Advertise with us

Among those principles is “All men are created equal” and the humanism that follows from it. Among the violations of those principles is the abusive, dismissive, contemptuous way Trump speaks about others, especially the vulnerable. I don’t think I need to give examples.

They should object, we should all object, because the problem isn’t just the way he is and the way he speaks as he tries to get what he wants. It’s that as president he affects the way the nation speaks and he does not affect it for the good.

He sets people against each other and encourages some people to despise others. The ties between very different people depend on at least pretending to respect each other and that requires speaking respectfully of each other, whatever we happen to think of them. The public order depends on comity, as the founding fathers put it, a practice of courtesy and consideration that creates social harmony, which wise people practice even if they don’t feel it.

Changing the limits

The problem with the president’s speech is that people act out the idea of others he articulates. By speaking so contemptuously about people he considers inferior or worse, he legitimizes that feeling for many people, even if they don’t realize it. The president, as president, is a model who sets standards.

We absorb a lot more than we realize. The public atmosphere, including the language we hear others use, moves us by making a belief or attitude feel normal, and we are people who naturally want to be normal, probably for evolutionary reasons.

Advertise with us

The effects aren’t usually obvious. People who once liked others can learn to feel dislike, discomfort or distrust for them, and lose sympathy for their struggles. They may not want ICE to pursue immigrants so energetically, but they don’t feel the reaction to their mistreatment that they once would have felt.

In some, of course, the effects are obvious. They suddenly start talking about others in the ways they had never done before, except maybe among their peers. They take the president’s speech as permission to say in public the hitherto forbidden.

As I’ve also written before, Trump could get done what he says he wants done without the theatrical cruelty — the genuinely fascist imagery of groups of armed, armored and masked officers jumping out of vans to grab people or breaking down the doors to get them in their homes — and the performative disregard for the good of others.

Illegal immigrants can be arrested humanely and treated well, even if you think they must be sent back to their home countries. Arrest others as you would have others arrest you, as one famous moral expert might have said. (Who was himself arrested, and very badly treated.)

A perfect picture

America recently saw a perfect picture of where Trump’s language leads, in the older man pulled out of his home in freezing weather in his underwear in front of his neighbors and others, with just a blanket for cover and plastic shoes on his feet. He was reportedly made to stand outside like that.

Advertise with us

The agents could easily have let him get dressed, but they didn’t, for no possible reason except contempt for him as an illegal alien. They may not have felt it, but they acted as if they did. They enacted the president’s speech.

ChongLy Thao turned out not to be an alien at all, much less an illegal one. He’s a citizen. But even if he had been here illegally, no human being should be treated that badly. That means that no group of people should be spoken in a way that encourages others to treat them that badly, especially by the nation’s most powerful model.

David Mills’s previous column was “Six political lessons from the Steelers' sad season.”

The previous entries are Peter Kalis’s “Donald Trump knows what the U.S. must do to survive”; Adriana E. Ramírez’s “Donald Trump has been a great president, for some”; Seth Cropsey’s “Donald Trump's operational masterstrokes”; and Gene Collier’s “A dark year with the Threatener-in-Chief.”