The Banned Book Week’s homepage offers resources for a “Right to Read Night” intended to “engage local networks in the fight to read freely.” For them, this fight is a great existential struggle against authoritarianism. I can’t find a way to say this gently. The whole enterprise is ridiculous. And worse, anti-democratic.

There is no fight to read freely. Find one free adult in America who can’t read anything he wants to read. You can read “Mein Kampf.” You can read “The Communist Manifesto.” You can read the unabomber’s manifesto. You can read the worst porn and the most trivial, mind-rotting rubbish. You can read posts on X. You can read any freaking thing you want.

There are no banned books in America, in any way that word makes sense.

The debates we have

What we have are disagreements over the nature of contested public spaces, almost all about public schools and public libraries, differences between people of very different convictions that can only be settled by discussion and negotiation. And particularly over how those public spaces treat our children.

Advertise with us

The banned books fervor is a way one group — basically, one portion of educated white upper-middle class urban and suburban liberals — tries to avoid negotiation and impose its will. It’s an attempt to find an objective standard that serves their cause and excludes others from being heard at all. (It’s the liberal version of the conservative Christian claim to speak for God against the godless secular woke liberals.)

A few years ago, our local library displayed a set of banned books with the usual earnest breathless slogans. I looked up one called “Bone,” because from the library’s description it seemed the most wrongly challenged. It turned out that the book was challenged by one parent in one elementary school in one conservative suburb, and after some discussion the school library kept it anyway.

However, the father’s concern wasn’t unreasonable, on the book establishment’s own grounds. It was rated as suitable for fourth graders and up, and an elementary school has a lot of children from kindergarten to third grade for whom it was presumably unsuitable. It stayed on the shelves anyway. And that was that.

But there it was, featured as an example of the great, the existential, danger to our freedom to read. When I’ve looked up other examples, that’s almost always the story. In other words, no story. And definitely nothing so end-of-democracy dramatic as the BBW people want us to believe.

We do face real threats to freedom of speech. FCC commissioner Brendan Carr’s thuggish threat to Jimmy Kimmel is an example. But that’s a subject for another time.

Advertise with us

Everyone makes choices

The reality is that our shared spaces, and especially our shared institutions, necessarily mean conflict.

The issue with public schools is who makes the choices for the children. The issue with public libraries is who makes the choices for the use of a public resource. The first is the greatest source of conflict.

Because everyone wants to restrict and direct what children read. We know they mature into understanding and too early exposure to some realities can hurt them. We also know they need to learn some realities they may not learn about anywhere but school. Americans disagree on which is which.

That’s why books get age ratings on the one hand and on the other public agencies run reading programs. That’s why we have a version of “Huckleberry Finn” with the offensive words removed, but people still want kids to read “Huckleberry Finn” even with the offensive words.

That’s why some people insist that schools must offer trans-friendly reading and other people insist they must not. That’s an issue that feels life or death for trans people and parents, and feels a matter of fundamental unchangeable principle to others. Compromise seems impossible, but the two have to find some way to share the same public spaces, because neither is going anywhere.

Advertise with us

In figuring out how to live together, each community must answer the question: Will the stakeholders, the parents and the public, make the inevitable choices that need to be made, or will the public employees they’ve deputized to teach their children and run a library make them? Who decides what books the kids will read, for example?

Most communities defer to the latter while making room for the former to involve themselves and protest if they want — to engage in the discussion and negotiation I mentioned. It’s a workable system, and the only one that makes sense when the stakeholders have deputized others to do the work for them, with the implicit promise of leaving them to do it.

Imperfect but necessary

Workable, but not perfect. Sometimes stakeholders will wreck things trying to take over, not respecting the teachers’ knowledge and experience. Sometimes the employees will claim an expertise and power they don’t have, like teachers who are not scrupulous in respecting the parents’ beliefs.

Communities must deal with the mess the way they deal with any conflict, like battles over the tax rate or who gets their street repaved first. Otherwise, some people will rule over others, which will only make the conflict more intense and more volatile. Especially when children are involved.

The Banned Books Week people encourage the conflicts to become more intense and volatile by so rigidly ruling out other ways of answering the community’s question of who chooses — by treating concerns about books’ effects on children as an assault on Americans’ freedom — ruling out the democratic answer, the discussion and negotiation, that alone can hold divided Americans together.

David Mills’s previous column was “Why can’t we all just get along?”.