The people who study these things say that our musical tastes are fixed in our mid-teen years and that seems to be true. Then the music matters to you in a way it doesn’t when you’re older, because choosing the music you listen to is part of figuring out who you are.
When and where you were living must help determine what music, bands, and songs you still like now, in my case decades later. Growing up in a liberal-left college town in the 70s, when the formative political events were the Vietnam war and the Watergate scandal, will give you (me, anyway) a low view of people in power and the institutions through which they exercise power.
The Kennedy administration’s now infamous “best and brightest,” trying to force the world to do their will, started and then bungled a pointless war, sacrificing over 50,000 American lives. They were succeeded by Richard Nixon and the Republicans, and that administration didn’t go so well either.
So this list will be familiar to many and probably predictable, at least to people my age. Sorry for that. And I’ve forgotten a bunch of songs, too.
Here are eight songs I remember that either taught me something or put into words something I already thought, and that I still listen to.
The first eight songs
The Who, “Won’t Get Fooled Again.” My favorite political rock song, which I sometimes listen to, turned up very loud, after hours of reading political news. And especially after seeing how many people in both parties assume the goodwill and competence of the leaders of their own party, I’m guessing because the more realistic alternative makes them feel we’re screwed. It ends, “Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.”
Pink Floyd, “The Wall.” An even angrier song, directed against the powerful, represented by a school teacher out of the book of stereotypes of awful English people, and their role in making everyone the same. The kids sing defiantly, “We don’t need no education. We don’t need no thought control,” but then end with resignation, “All in all you’re just another brick in the wall.”
The Rolling Stones, “Sympathy for the Devil.” Lucifer, who describes himself as “a man of wealth and taste,” demands sympathy and courtesy after explaining that he was behind the horrors of human history, including the Bolshevik Revolution. History is a place where evil flourishes, often masquerading as good.
Creedence Clearwater Revival, “Fortunate Son.” A protest against the system that sent young man to fight the pointless war. “Some folks inherit star spangled eyes. / Ooh, they send you down to war, Lord. / And when you ask them, ‘How much should we give?’ / Ooh, they only answer ‘More! More! More!’ ... It ain’t me, it ain’t me, I ain’t no fortunate one.”
The Beatles, “Back in the USSR” and “Revolution.” Their dismissals, the first sarcastic, of the romantics who idealized a nation they didn’t have to live in and a revolution they’d never experience. A helpful warning for those of us who enjoyed our political commitments in comfort and safety.
The Cranberries, “Zombie.” A similar warning.
Joni Mitchell, “Big Yellow Taxi.” Has the wonderful and famous lines, “They paved paradise and put up a parking lot” and “Don't it always seem to go, that you don't know what you got ’til it’s gone?” I laughed the first time I heard the song and it helped me see how differently people could value things, and how many would destroy the beautiful to turn it into the profitable.
I could add other songs if I had space, and remembered them. Obvious ones like The Clash’s, for example. I went to their first American concert. The only cool thing I’ve ever done. I also couldn’t hear for three weeks afterward. Many from the English Billy Bragg, whom I saw in Greensburg last year. And all the classics, like Woody Guthrie’s.
A hymn
G. K. Chesterton, “O God of Earth and Altar.” A hymn, not a rock song, but one of the wisest political songs I know, because it sees the reality of judgment on us and our own side and the possibility of a people forming a peaceable political community. (Though claimed by conservative Christians, Chesterton was politically a man of the left.)
Our problem isn’t just Trump being Trump, and politicians who’d seen through him abandoning their principles to suck up to him and enable him to do the damage he’s doing. It isn’t just Biden pretending to be competent and the people around him, the new best and brightest, hiding his decline to maintain their power.
It isn’t just all the [expletive] we see in our political life, which should be despised and fought. The problem is also us. And that means some of the hope for change is also us.
It begins: “O God of earth and altar, bow down and hear our cry, / our earthly rulers falter, our people drift and die; / the walls of gold entomb us, the swords of scorn divide, / take not thy thunder from us, but take away our pride.”
The second verse is equally pointed: “From all that terror teaches, from lies of tongue and pen, / from all the easy speeches that comfort cruel men, / from sale and profanation of honor, and the sword, / from sleep and from damnation, deliver us, good Lord.”
On the other hand, a Catholic priest told me that when he had this sung on a Memorial Day or July 4th Mass, parishioners complained that it wasn’t patriotic. Maybe if they don’t listen to Chesterton, they’ll listen to The Who and the Rolling Stones.
Please send me your own lists, especially those of you who listen to a lot more and newer music than I do. I’ll compile them into another column in a few weeks.
David Mills’ previous column was “Donald Trump believes God spared him in Butler to be even more Donald Trump.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.