The conflict in Los Angeles began with a lie. During the 2016 primaries, Donald Trump saw that taking a hard line on immigration, making illegal immigrants look as bad as he possibly could, would win him votes. It had not been an issue he had cared about before, but his aides reportedly told him it would separate him from the other candidates. All he needed to do was turn the issue up to 11, something at which he’s a master.
Now, in 2025, he sees that taking a hard line on people protesting his administration’s hardline tactics will win him support. People in the center, who may dislike him and even have voted against him, but who have never been comfortable with the “illegal” in illegal immigration and understandably react to chaos and disorder, will respond to someone who promises law and order.
It’s a winning issue for him — if people buy the lie.
Second term Trump
Then and now, Trump speaks of violent drug-dealing criminal hordes threatening American lives and welfare. They became the public enemy only he was facing.
The lie was that the “bad hombres” — as he put it in his debate with Hilary Clinton in 2016 — represented the undocumented. He spoke as if they were not only almost uniquely evil but were a large percentage of the undocumented.
He never admitted, as far as I can find, that the great majority of the undocumented are good citizens, who happen not to be citizens. They commit much less crime than others, and pay a lot in taxes but take little out of the system. And they do the jobs Americans want done, which means in practice want them to do. They’re here because we want them to be.
But second term Trump had a problem demonizing the bad hombres. There weren’t that many to arrest and deport, and he quickly ran out of the red meat photo ops he and his minions enjoyed. So they turned their attention to allegedly antisemitic immigrants, whose protests against Israel’s war on Gaza they declared a danger to national security and a violation of their immigration status.
But they quickly ran out of those, and some ICE picked up were ridiculously ill-chosen. So the administration turned to, and on, undocumented or illegal immigrants in general. This group provides an almost unlimited supply of people to grab and red meat photo ops to cheer the base. Suddenly millions of people who had lived quiet lives, contributing to American society, and prosperity, were dangers to the nation. People so bad they had to be removed right away, no matter the effect on their lives and their communities.
That was the lie that resulted in the conflict in Los Angeles. People eventually push back against the cruelty the lie justified. That was dangerous enough. The hard left exploited it, creating the chaos and disorder that only helps Trump. I’m sure Trump expected them to.
Trump’s special skill
This ability to make whole groups of people look bad is a skill Trump has had since before he was a national figure. In fact, exercising it helped make him a national figure. I’m talking about the Central Park 5 case. (My thanks for the quotes to Oliver Laughland, writing in The Guardian.)
In 1989, a white woman was brutally raped and beaten into unconsciousness while jogging at night in Central Park. The police quickly picked up five teenagers, four Black and one Hispanic, grilled them for hours, allegedly beat or threatened some of them, played the usual police interrogations tricks (that is, lied), and intimidated four of them into confessing.
They were innocent.
Trump took advantage of the outrage, paying for an ad in the city’s major newspapers in which, playing on stereotypes and fears, he lamented the loss of the good old days, described in lurid language how horrible things are now, praised the police, blamed the liberals, and demanded radical action. “Mayor Koch has stated that hate and rancor should be removed from our hearts,” he wrote. “I do not think so. I want to hate these muggers and murderers. They should be forced to suffer and when they kill, they should be executed for their crimes.”
Though he didn’t mention the Central Park Five, readers knew who he meant by “these muggers and murderers.”
Who were, again, innocent.
The five were convicted in 1995 and sent to prison. They were convicted mostly on the basis of their confessions, though why anyone would trust the New York City police in a case like that is a question. No DNA evidence linked them to the victim. In 2002, a rapist and murderer in prison confessed to the crime and DNA tests proved it.
Trump has never admitted having been wrong about the case.
One of his biographers, Michael D’Antonio, asked him if the case would hurt his political ambitions. “I think it will help me. I think people are tired of politically correct. I just attacked the Central Park Five settlement. Who’s going to do that?”
Trump’s impulse
Why did Trump do it? D’Antonio explained that he “has this penchant for what you might call otherising. I think he knew what he was doing by taking a side, and I think he knew he was aligning himself with law and order, especially white law and order. I don’t think that he was consciously saying ‘I’d like to whip up racial animosity,’ but his impulse is to run into conflict and controversy rather than try to help people understand what might be going on in a reasoned way.”
Add to that impulse the willingness to lie about the people he wants as his enemies, even if they’re innocent, and you get Los Angeles.
David Mills’ previous column was “Donald Trump, the annoying Constitution, and ‘sleazebag’ Leonard Leo.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.