“That’s the deepest cut,” the professor told me, “the role that seemingly orthodox Christians played in the rise of Donald Trump.” Gillis Harp was speaking of his fellow Evangelicals. He could deal better with the “horrific” Trumpian movement if so many of his fellow Evangelicals didn’t support it.
He recently retired as a historian at Grove City College, an Evangelical institution about an hour north of Pittsburgh. His last book was “Protestants and American Conservatism: A Short History.” He’s speaking of a world he knows.
The school, which flourishes, became famous in the mid-80s for rejecting all federal funding to keep its independence, and has become one of the intellectual bastions of Evangelical support for political conservatism.
Religion in public life
We’ve been friends for about three decades, and despite substantial religious differences, share an understanding of the place of Christianity in public life.
As I’d put it (Gil would use different terms), Christianity should stand for a complete commitment to universal human dignity, to the belief that no one is a means to anyone else’s ends, and to the conviction that we are our brother’s keeper and that the circle of our brothers is much wider than we think and should always be getting wider.
This means that the good of individuals matters as much as the good of any cause, any “greater good.” People cannot justify human suffering just with the claim that you can’t make an omelette without breaking eggs. It means that even in deep, bitter conflict — recognizing your place in a very diverse and pluralistic society — you strain to love your enemy and to do unto them as you would have them do unto you.
Read More
This idea can co-exist with a very wide range of positions, given how differently people read the world, from a humane form of libertarianism to a form of socialism that recognizes individual freedom. What matters is how you treat people and whether you’re pursuing their good as best you can in your circumstances.
I would have argued a few months ago that it was compatible with voting for Trump, for people who believed him the best choice in binary system. But what now, when he’s committed himself to a program of destruction causing untold human suffering? A cost to others that, as I’ve written, he didn’t need to impose to get what he wants. A program that’s unnecessarily cruel.
That raises the question that vexes Gil and me: Why have so many religious people gone all in for President Trump? Why the enthusiasm? Why the joyful sharing of lies and falsehoods you see on social media, their complete unquestioning acceptance of the entire Trump line?
I can understand their supporting him, believing that desperate times require desperate measures, but I can’t understand the joy they’re taking in the destruction he’s causing, why have they embraced a politics that seems to me so far from the fundamental Christian commitments.
Gil has an answer for his fellow Evangelicals, which I think applies to some politically conservative Catholics as well.
A new morality
In an article just published in the magazine Commonweal with the title “Rationalizing Trump,” Gil asks why 82% of his fellow white Evangelicals voted for him. (AP VoteCast reported that a slight majority of Latino evangelicals voted for him, as well as about 60% of white Catholics and of Mormons.)
One reason, he suggests, is their morality, but it’s not the morality you’d expect, of absolute right and absolute wrong, of thou shalt and thou shalt not. They’d held that morality in the past but at some point in the last few decades they’d given up the “traditional system of normative ethics based upon eternally valid principles” for what scholars call “consequentialism.”
The consequentialist “holds that good ends, however they might be defined, can justify the use of unethical means.” In other words, you can do something you know to be wrong if it offers the best way of getting something you think good.
The problem is obvious. We can convince ourselves that anything we want is good enough to justify doing something very bad to get. Like, oh, letting people getting American aid die because the federal bureaucracy, the “deep state,” must be crushed. This Evangelicals have done. Why they’ve done it is a question for another time.
Gil gives as an example Pete Hegseth’s confirmation hearings to become Secretary of Defense. “In his testimony, Hegseth frequently referenced his newfound Evangelical faith. He did so while simultaneously lamenting that American soldiers had been required to follow higher ethical standards and rules of engagement than those of ISIS terrorists.”
Presumably even Hegseth recognizes ISIS’s way of waging war to be deeply immoral. Immoral in the we-don’t-do-that-no-matter-what way Americans in his position had understood. The military holds to rules of engagement expressing America’s moral commitments. For violating the rules, like intentionally killing a civilian — that is, waging war like ISIS — a soldier can get court-martialed and spend decades in a military prison.
Shocked and disoriented
But consequentialist Hegseth’s hugely popular with Evangelicals, as is Donald Trump. To find his fellow Evangelicals so committed to a politics and a politician he thinks inhuman makes Gil (and me) feel “shocked and disoriented.”
Religion and religious communities anchor religious people in the world, give them a fixed point in a chaotic and changing world. It matters to them what the people with whom they worship think and do, whether it’s still the kind of community that helps make them better people — people who will not cheer a program of needless destruction whatever good may come of it and will speak up for the victims.
David Mills’ previous column was “JD Vance the 13th century Trumpian thinker.” Gillis Harp’s article can be found here.
Two changes were made at the subject’s request.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.