The attack on the Capitol by an armed mob on Jan. 6, 2021 — we observed the third anniversary yesterday — appears at first glance to have few historical precedents. The obvious one is South Carolina secessionists firing on Fort Sumter at the start of the Civil War in April 1861. Some of the Jan. 6 mob did underline the parallel by carrying Confederate flags.

But another historical precedent — and one closer to home — may offer an illuminating comparison to January 6th. Further, the reaction of self-identified “conservative” political leaders to the insurrectionary violence then and now provides a revealing contrast.

A Western Pa. uprising

The Whiskey Rebellion of 1794 was a violent uprising in western Pennsylvania against a federal tax on distilled alcohol. Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton (one of the leaders of the conservative Federalist party) introduced the controversial tax as part of his larger fiscal program. When federal marshals delivered court summons to those who had refused to pay the excise, thousands of opponents assembled near Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

The opposition mob chose to target John Neville who had helped deliver the writs. One July evening, they surrounded his home at Bower Hill and soon gunfire was exchanged. With casualties on both sides, the defenders in the house surrendered the following morning. Roughly two weeks later, perhaps 7,000 rebels assembled about eight miles from Pittsburgh in Braddock’s Field and prepared to attack the city.

An alarmed Hamilton immediately wrote to President George Washington. Fundamental issues were at stake. One draft of his letter asked “whether a small minority of the community shall control & defeat the will of the majority declared through its constitutional representatives? In other words, whether anarchy shall take place of Government?” John Adams, in a later letter to Thomas Jefferson, referred to the Rebellion frankly as an example of “Terrorism.”

Did the evangelicals of the day sympathize with the rebels? Mostly not. Protestant clergy, especially those in New England who openly backed the Federalist party, denounced what they viewed as the anarchic forces seeking to undermine legal authority.

Some saw the Rebellion as the disturbing fruit of the violence and infidelity unleashed by the French Revolution. They preached what scholars term “Jeremiads” against this rather American insurrectionary impulse. Yale’s president, the indomitable Timothy Dwight, often called “the Federalist Pope,” viewed such uprisings against state authority as clear evidence of moral degeneracy.

When initial attempts to talk with the malcontents failed, the president chose dramatic action. He did not equivocate or delay. He didn’t ignore his advisors, eat his lunch, and read newspapers (the eighteenth-century equivalent of watching television). To demonstrate that the new national government meant business, Washington called up nearly thirteen thousand state militia and personally led them westward from Philadelphia, then the national capital.

Advertise with us

Washington also issued a strongly worded official proclamation to clarify the larger issues at stake. In it, he characterized the revolt as an “insurrection” and observed that “many persons in the said western parts of Pennsylvania have at length been hardy enough to perpetrate acts, which I am advised amount to treason, being overt acts of levying war against the United States.”

The rebels’ fatal spirit

Having been advised by Supreme Court Justice James Wilson that federal laws could no longer be properly enforced in Washington and Allegheny counties, Washington reluctantly concluded “that the very existence of government and the fundamental principles of social order are materially involved in the issue, and that the patriotism and firmness of all good citizens are seriously called upon, as occasions may require, to aid in the effectual suppression of so fatal a spirit.”

As the large military force — commanded by Washington himself — neared Pittsburgh, the rebels fled, and the rebellion fizzled. The massive show of federal authority had worked. Nearly two dozen insurrectionists were indicted, about half stood trial and two were eventually found guilty of treason and sentenced to death, though Washington later pardoned them.

Considering the more recent events of Jan. 6, 2021, at least a couple observations spring to mind. First, unlike the 45th president, the first president sprang into action when violent mobs defied the law and assaulted law enforcement.

Advertise with us

Unlike the Republican National Committee, Federalist party leaders did not then characterize the rebellion as “legitimate political discourse.” They candidly labeled the revolt a treasonous insurrection. Nor did they call those duly arrested “political prisoners.”

The leaders of America’s first conservative party believed in a strong federal government and sought to discourage the young republic’s citizens from taking the law into their own hands. Further, their Christian allies did not excuse the rebellion but attacked it head on, interpreting it as an ominous sign of a dark spiritual malaise.

The Federalists’ political opponents did not like the administration’s response. Thomas Jefferson and James Madison (the latter then a leading member of Congress) thought it was excessive but mostly kept quiet publicly since they had agreed to a political compromise that included Hamilton’s controversial tax.

Madison nevertheless expressed relief in a letter to James Monroe that “the people every where and of every description condemned the resistance of the will of the Majority, and obeyed with alacrity the call to vindicate the authority of the laws.”

Stabilizing the Republic

Advertise with us

The prompt and powerful response helped enhance and bolster the authority of the newly minted federal government and served to stabilize and secure the new republic. What would have happened to America had Washington not acted as he did is an open question, but letting the rebels succeed in their lawlessness could well have derailed the young nation’s growth into a truly unified nation.

Decisive action by the first chief executive and the full-throated support by his conservative party along with their evangelical supporters contrasts sharply with the shameful non-response of the 45th president and the obfuscations of his Republican apologists.

It’s enough to make a person nostalgic about a time when conservatives were the party of law and order.

Gillis Harp is professor of history at Grove City College and author of “Protestants and American Conservatism: A Short History.”