When I was a kid, a book called “Love Story” became a huge bestseller, and the movie made from the book, with its two heart throb leads, was a huge hit.
Together they made popular the line “Love means never having to say you’re sorry.” People invoked it all the time, the way some people quote Bible verses, as an infallible, unquestionable truth.
And it’s absolute rubbish.
The need for apology
Love means saying sorry a lot. You’ve committed yourself to someone else — a spouse, a child, a friend — but you will not always honor that commitment. The only way to repair the relation when you’ve damaged it is to admit it and apologize. The other person needs to hear it and you need to say it.
We all know this. Just think of the drunken uncle who ruins Thanksgiving dinner and has never said he’s sorry. Or the co-worker who’s always screwing up and laughs it off. You’d feel 100% better if they just once showed real remorse. Things might get better after the apology. They won’t get better without it.
There’s a political point to this. A healthy society requires leaders who know when they’ve done wrong and will admit it in public, and will take any punishment the people (voters, for example) give them. That makes them better leaders and our relation with them more trusting.
But a healthy society requires more than that. It requires apologies we can trust. And we can’t naively trust apologies from people in power, because we live in a world where very smart people specialize in whitewashing dirtied reputations, and powerful people can pay them to do it.
It’s part of an enterprise called “reputation management.” The managers don’t care if their clients mean it, and have no interest in whether their clients are truly sorry. The job is to make the people their clients hurt think they’re sorry. It is, sadly, that cynical.
White Sox non-apology
We have what I think is an example of this in a letter from the owner of the White Sox, Jerry Reinsdorf, to the team’s justifiably angry fans. The team won 41 games this year and lost 121. It was the worst team in baseball history.
When I first saw the letter, I thought, “Yay for him,” but then I read it. It has all the marks of being written by a reputation management firm. Here’s how these things work.
First, apologize for the horrendously bad team without actually calling it an horrendously bad team (he begins the letter, “By all measures, our on-field performance this season was a failure”). You don’t want to admit too much.
Then take full responsibility for it without saying specifically what you did wrong (“As the leader of this organization, that is my ultimate responsibility. There are no excuses.”). Again, don’t admit too much.
Having gotten the hard stuff out of the way, promise to make things better by doing things you would be doing anyway (“further development of players on our current roster, development of players within our system, evaluating the trade and free agent markets,” etc.). You get credit for acting decisively when you’re not.
At that point, hoping your readers have bought it all, tell them that you’re already doing something (the general manager, called by his first name, has the search for a new manager “well underway”). Then insist there’s good news and hope for the future, that’s not easily verifiable (“The overall health of our organization is improving. Our minor league rankings show this growth.”). You hope they buy this too.
Close by sharing your own pain (“Every loss this season — every blown save, every defensive miscue, every shut out, every sweep — hurt”). Promise to do better, admitting that you need to earn their trust. Try to make them feel sorry for you and on your side.
What is missing? The main, the central, the crucial promise fans want: the promise to spend a lot more money on the team. All the owner has said is that he’ll keep doing what he’s doing, which led to the worst season in baseball history, only he’ll do better this time.
Is Mr. Reinsdorf truly sorry? Who knows? Were I a White Sox fan, I wouldn’t believe him. He let the team get this bad and, again, he’s not promising to do the one thing he needs to do. I’d bet on the team only losing 110 games next season.
If a baseball owner can do this, a national or state politician can do it. And they do.
Alex Cora’s example
I think in contrast of Alex Cora, the Red Sox manager, after winning the playoff series against the favored Rays in 2021. He’d been caught cheating with a previous team, suspended from baseball for a year and fired from his job.
“She suffered a lot and it was my fault,” Cora said when his little daughter ran up to him while he was being interviewed. “And sometimes we make bad decisions, and I made a horrible decision in baseball and I paid the price. But what really hurt me was for them to suffer because of my mistakes.”
He seemed to be telling the truth. It didn’t sound scripted.
We need leaders like Alex Cora running baseball teams, and running the country.
David Mills’s previous column was “Rowdy Tellez, Bob Nutting and what it (should) mean to own a team.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.