When I was a kid, a book called “Love Story” be­came a huge best­seller, and the movie made from the book, with its two heart throb leads, was a huge hit.

To­gether they made pop­u­lar the line “Love means never hav­ing to say you’re sorry.” People invoked it all the time, the way some people quote Bible verses, as an infallible, unquestionable truth.

And it’s ab­so­lute rub­bish.

The need for apol­ogy

Love means say­ing sorry a lot. You’ve com­mit­ted your­self to some­one else — a spouse, a child, a friend — but you will not al­ways honor that com­mit­ment. The only way to re­pair the re­la­tion when you’ve dam­aged it is to ad­mit it and apol­o­gize. The other per­son needs to hear it and you need to say it.

Advertise with us

We all know this. Just think of the drunken un­cle who ru­ins Thanks­giv­ing din­ner and has never said he’s sorry. Or the co-worker who’s al­ways screw­ing up and laughs it off. You’d feel 100% bet­ter if they just once showed real re­morse. Th­ings might get bet­ter af­ter the apol­ogy. They won’t get bet­ter with­out it.

There’s a po­lit­i­cal point to this. A healthy so­ci­ety re­quires lead­ers who know when they’ve done wrong and will ad­mit it in pub­lic, and will take any pun­ish­ment the peo­ple (vot­ers, for ex­am­ple) give them. That makes them bet­ter lead­ers and our re­la­tion with them more trusting.

But a healthy so­ci­ety re­quires more than that. It re­quires apol­o­gies we can trust. And we can’t na­ively trust apol­o­gies from peo­ple in power, be­cause we live in a world where very smart peo­ple spe­cial­ize in white­wash­ing dirt­ied rep­u­ta­tions, and powerful people can pay them to do it.

It’s part of an en­ter­prise called “rep­u­ta­tion man­age­ment.” The man­ag­ers don’t care if their cli­ents mean it, and have no in­ter­est in whether their cli­ents are truly sorry. The job is to make the peo­ple their cli­ents hurt think they’re sorry. It is, sadly, that cyn­i­cal.

White Sox non-apol­ogy

We have what I think is an ex­am­ple of this in a let­ter from the owner of the White Sox, Jerry Reins­dorf, to the team’s jus­ti­fi­ably an­gry fans. The team won 41 games this year and lost 121. It was the worst team in base­ball his­tory.

Advertise with us

When I first saw the letter, I thought, “Yay for him,” but then I read it. It has all the marks of be­ing writ­ten by a rep­u­ta­tion man­age­ment firm. Here’s how these things work.

First, apol­o­gize for the hor­ren­dously bad team with­out ac­tu­ally call­ing it an hor­ren­dously bad team (he be­gins the let­ter, “By all mea­sures, our on-field per­for­mance this sea­son was a fail­ure”). You don’t want to ad­mit too much.

Then take full re­spon­si­bil­ity for it with­out say­ing spe­cif­i­cally what you did wrong (“As the leader of this or­ga­ni­za­tion, that is my ul­ti­mate re­spon­si­bil­ity. There are no ex­cuses.”). Again, don’t ad­mit too much.

Hav­ing got­ten the hard stuff out of the way, prom­ise to make things bet­ter by do­ing things you would be do­ing any­way (“fur­ther de­vel­op­ment of play­ers on our cur­rent ros­ter, de­vel­op­ment of play­ers within our sys­tem, eval­u­at­ing the trade and free agent mar­kets,” etc.). You get credit for act­ing de­ci­sively when you’re not.

At that point, hop­ing your read­ers have bought it all, tell them that you’re al­ready do­ing some­thing (the gen­eral man­ager, called by his first name, has the search for a new man­ager “well un­der­way”). Then in­sist there’s good news and hope for the fu­ture, that’s not easily verifiable (“The over­all health of our or­ga­ni­za­tion is im­prov­ing. Our mi­nor league rank­ings show this growth.”). You hope they buy this too.

Advertise with us

Close by shar­ing your own pain (“Every loss this sea­son — ev­ery blown save, ev­ery de­fen­sive mis­cue, ev­ery shut out, ev­ery sweep — hurt”). Promise to do bet­ter, ad­mit­ting that you need to earn their trust. Try to make them feel sorry for you and on your side.

What is miss­ing? The main, the cen­tral, the cru­cial prom­ise fans want: the prom­ise to spend a lot more money on the team. All the owner has said is that he’ll keep do­ing what he’s do­ing, which led to the worst sea­son in base­ball his­tory, only he’ll do bet­ter this time.

Is Mr. Reins­dorf truly sorry? Who knows? Were I a White Sox fan, I wouldn’t be­lieve him. He let the team get this bad and, again, he’s not prom­is­ing to do the one thing he needs to do. I’d bet on the team only los­ing 110 games next sea­son.

If a baseball owner can do this, a national or state politician can do it. And they do.

Alex Cora’s ex­am­ple

I think in con­trast of Alex Cora, the Red Sox man­ager, af­ter win­ning the play­off se­ries against the fa­vored Rays in 2021. He’d been caught cheat­ing with a pre­vi­ous team, sus­pended from base­ball for a year and fired from his job.

Advertise with us

“She suf­fered a lot and it was my fault,” Cora said when his lit­tle daugh­ter ran up to him while he was be­ing in­ter­viewed. “And some­times we make bad de­ci­sions, and I made a hor­ri­ble de­ci­sion in base­ball and I paid the price. But what re­ally hurt me was for them to suf­fer be­cause of my mis­takes.”

He seemed to be tell­ing the truth. It didn’t sound scripted.

We need leaders like Alex Cora running baseball teams, and running the country.

David Mills’s previous column was “Rowdy Tellez, Bob Nutting and what it (should) mean to own a team.”