The poster in the break room of my dad’s office — a cartoon drawn in pastels in the poor imitation of Sgt. Peppers style popular then — showed a man behind the steering wheel looking sideways at a young woman in a short skirt, with the words, imperatively sized, “Eyes front, mac!”

Even as a teenager I knew that no slogan on a poster could restrain a man whose attention was caught by a young woman in a short skirt. With the advantage of decades, I’ve learned, with some pain, that words by themselves don’t do much. We do what we do because we’re wired to do it, and though we can rewire ourselves, to some extent, we have to want to change and work at it.

The governor and legislature of Louisiana don’t seem to understand this or, as I suspect, don’t care to think about it because they have other reasons than moral instruction for posting the Ten Commandments on the walls of every public school classroom in the state.

Just words on walls

A poster may give the best advice in the world, but no one’s going to take it just because they saw it on a poster. That’s not the way human beings work. We don’t learn from slogans on walls. We often don’t learn from our friends, so definitely not from slogans on walls.

Advertise with us

Least of all, from official slogans imposed from above. My dad, who agreed with me, said they’d gotten it from someone in Washington with the instructions to display it where it would be seen.

That’s not the way human beings work and it’s not the way human morality works. Words on a wall don’t do much if anything to change human behavior, especially words given as short statements of general rules, that someone somewhere decided we should see. What should anyone care?

People don’t even always remember the words they choose. At least three times in my life, I’ve said something encouraging or inspiring to someone who was sad or upset and had a version of this exchange: “Why do you say that?” “Because you have it on your refrigerator.”

That’s one reason not to put the Ten Commandments (also called the Decalogue) on classroom walls. Doing that’s less likely to encourage children to live better lives than it is to make them ignore and then forget about the rules entirely.

It’s more likely to make the Ten Commandments part of the background decoration of their childhood, like the big letters of the alphabet that circled the wall in the lower grades. It makes them something you outgrow, like sounding out words or sleeping with stuffed toys.

Advertise with us

I would be surprised if a single child, unless he had a serious religious upbringing, graduates from a Louisiana high school knowing all the Ten Commandments, much less having any idea what they mean.

They don’t mean it

But I don’t think they — Gov. Jeff Landry and his legislative colleagues, which included Democrats as well as Republicans — care that much about the Ten Commandments as a moral guide. I’m fairly sure they’re not so much thinking about the moral formation of children as the political value of putting together “schools” and “God” to make a statement against the liberals, presumed to be secular and godless. The Ten Commandments make a great prop.

I think this for two reasons. First, the way they talk about it. “I’m going home to sign a bill that places the Ten Commandments in public classrooms, and I can’t wait to be sued,” Landry told a Republican fundraising dinner in Tennessee, after speaking of “the grip of anarchy that has infected the country.” He made it political.

The second reason, which I think even more telling, is that the new Louisiana law doesn’t require schools to teach the Decalogue. If you truly think it matters, you will insist teachers tell their students what it means. You won’t just stick it on a wall.

It’s a short statement whose meaning isn’t obvious. Who is this God we’re supposed to worship? Can we kill to defend others? How do we honor abusive parents? What does “covet” mean anyway? You can find, in the Jewish and Christian traditions, many profound expositions of the Decalogue, but they tend to run long because teasing out the subtleties takes time.

Advertise with us

Performative, not educational

Louisiana’s attempt to impose the Ten Commandments, like most or all of the preceding attempts in other states, seems performative rather than educational. If you believe the Ten Commandments of divine inspiration, as the governor and the legislators seem to do, using them to make a political statement is a kind of blasphemy.

The first commandment says, “You shall have no other gods before me,” and those gods include political success. The religious person believes the sacred things, including the sacred words, to be divine gifts to be cared for, to be treasured, not objects to be used against others for our own purposes.

Never mind offending the Constitution. The people who use the Ten Commandments to make a political statement risk offending God Almighty.

David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Our political class is ruining our language”.