The prophet went to the palace to see the king, and told him that a rich man, who had lots of sheep, had taken a poor man’s pet lamb to feed a visitor. The man, said the prophet, laying it on, had only the one lamb, which grew up with his children and ate from his plate, and was like a daughter to him.

The enraged king declared that the rich man should die. He saw himself, I’m guessing, as the good man with the power to punish the wicked and to get justice for their victims. It’s a great feeling.

Then the prophet said, “You are the man.” He’d played the king very nicely. The king had ordered a man killed so he could take his wife for his own. He had done something even more evil than the rich man whose death he demanded. And, to his credit, he knew it. He took his punishment, which did not include the death that would have been a just punishment by his own standards.

The king was King David, a morally conflicted man if there ever was one, and the story’s recorded in the second book of Samuel. It’s a very useful lesson in all sorts of ways. Here I want to use it as a lesson for dealing with the hatred people feel for each other, which seems to spread and spread, and which many of us feel ourselves.

Advertise with us

The hateful

As part of doing my job, I skim through a lot of political writing, beginning with the day’s emails from political publications of all sorts. Some of them (not all), gosh.

Every message screams and screeches, or sneers and spits, which I find more annoying. The writers see everyone on the other side as completely evil, completely wrong, entirely empty of any virtue or any truth. It’s very tiresome. I feel like I’m being punched over and over.

And it’s boring, too. No one’s interesting when they’re screeching or sneering. Even when I think I might learn something from them, I can’t read them, or not without effort. Why do people whose job is to change people’s minds do this? You can’t sell something to someone you hate.

Worse, I hate the people who hate. I try not to, but I feel it anyway, and I think others do as well. In other words, the problem is that hate just makes more people hateful, even people who don’t want to be. And once you start hating, stopping can be hard.

The writer-politician Vaclav Havel gave one explanation for why people hate. Havel, whom I’ve written about before, had been one of the leaders of the Czech dissident movement, standing with great courage against the communist regime, and becoming the free nation’s first president after the regime fell in the “Velvet Revolution” of 1989.

Advertise with us

“Collective hatred,” he said in an address to a conference on "the anatomy of hate” the next year, “eliminates loneliness, weakness, powerlessness, a sense of being ignored or abandoned. This, of course, helps people deal with lack of recognition, lack of success, because it offers them a sense of togetherness. It creates a strange brotherhood, founded on a simple form of mutual understanding that makes no demands whatsoever.”

This creates “a community of those who hate.” The members “can endlessly reassure one another of their own worth, either through exaggerated expressions of hatred for the chosen group of offenders, or through a cult of symbols and rituals that affirm the worth of the hating community.” You know you’re in because you know all those people are out.

These communities draw in the vulnerable. The community of those who hate has “a special magnetic attraction and therefore has the power to draw countless other people into its vortex, people who did not initially seem endowed with the ability to hate. They are merely small and morally weak, selfish people with lazy intellects, incapable of thinking for themselves, and therefore susceptible to the suggestive influence of those who hate.”

And it encourages people to violence. Being in a group “creates the illusion of legitimacy,” Havel noted. “Hidden within a group, a pack, or a mob, every potentially violent person can dare to do more; each one eggs the other on, and all of them — precisely because there are more of them — justify one another.”

King David’s lesson

Here’s where King David’s story helps. Unless you’re a very good person, you at least despise your enemies. (Despise being about 3/4s of full hate.) You may not have many, but you despise the ones you have. They’re dangerous and they’re bad. And if you can hate them as part of a collective or a community, and you can! all the better.

Advertise with us

David’s story teaches us that we may well be the thing we judge. Which may be why hating it comes so easily. People love quoting Socrates’ declaration that the unexamined life is not worth living, but when you really examine your life, you may find yourself looking in the mirror and saying, “You are the man.”

One way to answer hate is to look at the haters as a concrete example of the person you are to some extent and don’t want to be. Use them as a negative example. Start with not hating them, which may take a lot of work, and move out from there.

David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “The right’s careless, reckless, sneaky propaganda.” Havel’s address can be found in his book “The Art of the Impossible.”