According to the political statistician Nate Silver, “there are relatively few swing voters in the United States. But there are some, and with the country divided roughly 50/50, they usually determine who wins.”
Some portion of an electorate of over 160 million voters remain in play, still unsure if they want to vote for Donald Trump or Joe Biden, and open to persuasion. If he’s right, they’ll decide who runs America for the next four years.
Stark differences
I may well be missing something, but try as I might, I can’t get into the head of someone who genuinely wavers between Trump and Biden. I can’t see being a swing voter in this election. The differences are too stark. That’s like wavering between Ukraine and Russia, or good health and cancer, beer and sewage, the Steelers and the Cowboys. Opinions will differ on which is which, but the difference is going to feel that great.
Certainly many voters have swung in the last four years. According to the New York Times, while 97% of the people who voted for Donald Trump in 2020 will vote for him this time, and almost none of them will vote for Joe Biden, only 83% of Biden’s 2020 voters say they’re voting for him and 10% say they’re voting for Trump. They’re not swing voters anymore.
The only kind of swing voter that makes sense in this election is one who’s wavering between voting for his preferred candidate and not voting or voting for a third party. The hold-your-nose-and-vote voter might reasonably be caught between his feeling that his preferred candidate is a lesser evil, because he’ll do the things that desperately need doing, and his feeling that his candidate is so bad he shouldn’t be in office at all, even if that means the other guy wins. He could easily become the I’m outta here voter.
I can understand the Trump supporter who believes that the next president must — for the nation’s survival — reduce taxes and regulation, secure the border, push back against wokeness, and avoid foreign entanglements, yet sees Trump as so bad a man he shouldn’t be elected.
I can understand the Biden supporter who believes the next president must — for the nation’s survival — continue to spend money on making the country better, treat immigrants generously, and nominate liberal judges for the Supreme Court, yet sees Biden as so old or too committed to waging war he shouldn’t be elected.
That kind of swing voter makes sense. The rest of us know that Trump will face Biden and know already the choice we’ll make.
It doesn’t matter
This means that as far as the presidential campaign goes, what happens politically in the next eight (eight!) months till election day doesn’t matter to us. We’re not — barring some huge development — going to change our vote. And that presents an opportunity to do something more fruitful than keeping up with Trump and Biden, and obsessing, as many of us tend to do, because politics and the rage and elation it creates is addictive, over every little bit of news, no matter how inconsequential.
The English Catholic writer Caryll Houselander had a young friend who had gotten mentally wrapped up in politics, which left him anxious and unhappy. I’m guessing from the context that he began to feel that things were just getting worse and worse and people like him couldn’t do much about it, and the political system he wanted to trust wasn’t going to make his country better. It’s a feeling many of us know. It’s the reason being a hold-your-nose voter tempts so many.
Houselander told him to stop reading about politics. She put him on a reading plan, expecting that the books he read would re-form him and give him a wiser understanding of the world he lived in.
She suggested religious reading for a religious purpose, of course, but the general instruction applies to anyone. You can put it in humanist terms. He doesn’t have time to read all the books he should, she said. “This being so, it is wise to choose ones most likely to increase your consciousness of the presence of God, and ones most likely to enter into your mind and to enrich it forever.”
A year or two of closely reading books “about God which teach the soul to rest in Him,” she said, would change him. “You would afterwards find that you view hard, controversial matters much more easily. When I say ‘rest in Him,’ I don’t mean any sort of complacency or any sort of cessation of activity or activity of mind, but a rest like the rest in the wings of a bird spread upon and abandoned to the current of a great wind, swifter and stronger than its own flight.”
Truths to rest in
The idea is to stop thinking about political news that doesn’t practically matter to us and to spend the untold hours we gain reading and thinking about deeper matters, about the things that underlie our politics, culture and society, that are more intensely human than is politics, and matter infinitely more. Read the great religious writings, the major novels and poems, the best philosophers, works from other cultures, about lives you don’t know about and people you don’t understand.
Read to gain understanding and truths you can rest in, and therefor view politics itself, and politicians like Trump and Biden, more wisely.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor and columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “What makes ‘Fiddler on the Roof’ so sad.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.