Depending on how you understand the world, you may think the Christmas story plausible and true, plausible but untrue, implausible but who knows, implausible but untrue, or ridiculous. But it seems to me natural that we’d want it to be true as a statement about the deepest truth of the world, even if not true as a statement about human history.
The story’s the story of a baby who wasn’t just a baby, but the answer to everything. The one who, as the last book in the Bible says, at the end of history “shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain: for the former things are passed away.”
The world sucks. For many people, it sucks 24/7. We want to believe that whatever or whoever runs the universe saw our distress and joined us, so that we could enjoy some happiness in this world and complete happiness in the next, that good battles evil in the world now and will eventually win.
Pope Francis and the baby
One way to understand Pope Francis is that he believes the story to be true, as history and as story. God’s incarnation as a human was the perfect act of love, which human beings, including most Catholics, fail to imitate very well. (I include myself in that.)
The pope tries to make the Christmas story’s promise more obvious and more practical in the Catholic church’s life. That includes extending the visible signs of God’s love to everyone, including — or especially — those Catholics have traditionally pushed away. That baby came for everyone, even those who don’t know it.
The pope tries to do this in the statement “Fiducia Supplicans,” issued a week ago and in nanoseconds the subject of condemnation from the Catholic right and praise from the Catholic and secular left. Both got it wrong.
It didn’t help that the press, and especially the editors who write headlines, almost universally bungled the story. They wrote it as if the pope had approved a version of same-sex marriage and had crossed a hitherto uncrossable line.
The statement itself says in the third and fourth paragraphs that it does not change “in any way” the church’s teaching. It makes some effort, in about 5,000 words, to make crucial distinctions, including that between offering God’s blessing to people and approving of everything they do.
Many reporters and others seem to think that a blessing is a seal of approval. It’s in fact a request for God’s help. “One who asks for a blessing shows himself to be in need of God’s saving presence in his life,” the statement explains. The pope thinks people who aren’t living by all the church’s rules should still be given a blessing when they ask.
What’s Francis doing?
What is Francis doing in “Fiducia Supplicans”? Two theologians, both conservative as that’s usually defined, as am I, see what the pope is doing.
Holly Taylor Coolman, who teaches at Providence College, described the heart of the statement as the claim that when people ask a priest for a blessing, he should not make “an exhaustive moral analysis” the precondition for giving it. They “should not be required to have prior moral perfection.”
She explains: “This is not only the ordinary practice of priests in pastoral ministry, but it is close to the heart of the gospel: ‘We love because he first loved us.’ My only suggestion right now is that we linger a bit in I John: ‘God is love, and whoever remains in love remains in God and God in him.’”
Robert Barron says that “Fiducia Supplicans is very much congruent with Pope Francis’s long-held conviction that those who do not live up to the full demand of the Church’s moral teaching are nevertheless loved and cherished by God and invited to accept the Lord’s offer of forgiveness.”
Not being a theologian, I grant that the theology may be as problematic as some theologians say (theologians who are not among the Francis-haters). I don’t think it is, but even if problematic, it offers another step along the trajectory set by that baby in the manger. If the church doesn’t offer this kind of blessing, Catholics must find other ways to show God’s love to particular people, not just declare it in words. “Merry Christmas” should mean more than an extra-special “Good day to you.”
As the statement explains, the blessing expresses God’s love for humanity, which includes helping humans love other humans. The blessing brings “inclusion, solidarity, and peacemaking. It is a positive message of comfort, care, and encouragement. The blessing expresses God’s merciful embrace and the Church’s motherhood, which invites the faithful to have the same feelings as God toward their brothers and sisters.”
More than our sins
As Francis has written, “We are more important to God than all the sins we can commit because he is father, he is mother, he is pure love, he has blessed us forever. And he will never stop blessing us.”
That’s the God who gave us the baby and the story so many people love, whether they believe or not, because it speaks to the hope we have for the world, a world that sucks now, that love really is at the center of things.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor and columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Forget the college playoff scandal, read Vonnegut and feel better about the world.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.