“Live not by lies,” Alexander Solzhenitsyn declared in a 1974 essay that he issued as he was being exiled from the Soviet Union. He was too famous to imprison or kill, famous for his books, especially “The Gulag Archipelago” about the communist regime’s extensive system of prison camps, and for the Nobel Prize awarded to him in 1970. Even as brutal a regime as the Soviet one didn’t want to be more internationally despised than it was already.
He’d refused to live by the Soviet lie, which cost him years in some of the worst prisons on the planet, and when he was out of prison constant harassment and abuse, and the continuous threat of going back to prison. And then when the Soviets wanted to be done with him, he lost his homeland. He wanted to stay in Russia, as hard as his life was there.
He was a hero, who probably lied less in his life than a typical politician lies in a day. In one notable case, in an hour. His insight applies not just to totalitarian states but to democratic ones. To our story of the first Thanksgiving, for example.
Violence needs lies
The Soviet regime lied both to justify itself and to make its life easier. “Violence has nothing to cover itself with but lies, and lies can only persist through violence,” Solzhenitsyn wrote.
On the one hand, the brutal want to look (most of the time) kind. On the other, ruling’s easier if people accept untruths — at least live as if they do — than if the state must force them to obey. A totalitarian regime wants to look like a gentle shepherd — except when it needs to remind everyone it’s really a wolf — and it wants its sheep to look like trusting sheep.
Read More
The state “demands of us only a submission to lies, a daily participation in deceit,” Solzhenitsyn explained. As a famous Soviet-era joke went: “They pretend to pay me and I pretend to work.” That state could only fall if people stopped speaking as if they believed it.
Solzhenitsyn said no to the whole system. “Our way must be: Never knowingly support lies!” he said (the italics are his).
He made this concrete with a list of nine ways the honest person would not lie. The good man “will not write, sign, nor publish in any way, a single line distorting, so far as he can see, the truth,” for example. He will walk out of any event when someone says “a lie, ideological drivel, or shameless propaganda” and he will not lie, even in a little way, to protect or advance himself.
Recognizing our lies
Recognizing a lie was easy for Solzhenitsyn. If the state said it, it was almost certainly a lie. Or if true, an inconsequential truth.
But it’s not as easy for us. Some of our founding stories are basically true. But others aren’t. Any state, even a generally democratic one, wants people to believe some lies because it wants them to live a certain way, and live that way willingly.
Societies naturally create self-justifying myths. When, for example, their founding and growth included a lot of cruelty and theft and even murder, which upset the preferred image of the new nation as a kind of Garden of Eden.
We’re coming up on one of our nation’s most important founding stories. It’s the story of different people becoming friends, of the stronger welcoming and helping the weaker, and both coming together over a feast to thank their gods for all the good things they have, including each other. And it’s more a lie than a truth.
The commonly told story
This is the story as it’s still commonly told. “The myth is that friendly Indians, unidentified by tribe, welcome the Pilgrims to America, teach them how to live in this new place, sit down to dinner with them and then disappear,” says historian David Silverman in an interview in The Smithsonian.
“They hand off America to white people so they can create a great nation dedicated to liberty, opportunity and Christianity for the rest of the world to profit. That’s the story — it’s about Native people conceding to colonialism. It’s bloodless.”
Silverman explains that the story of the dinner became an important story at the end of the 19th century. He argues that the story justified the white Protestant supremacy in the face of growing numbers of Catholic and Jewish immigrants. It also showed the founding as an act of friendship and separated it from the uncomfortable realities of slavery and the oppression of people who got here first.
Question the nice stories
How do we live not by our own society’s lies? Learn to question stories that are too smooth and nice and sentimental, and too supportive of the way things supposedly were. Read widely and in sources likely to challenge the story.
We can still give thanks for what our ancestors did well, and I think this deepens our gratitude by making sure it’s well-directed. We give thanks for what we have, and not for a made-up history we don’t.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor and columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “The ‘diabolically disordered clown’ Pope Francis teaches us how to see.” Solzhenitsyn’s essay can be found here and the interview with David Silverman here.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.