“Live not by lies,” Al­ex­an­der Solz­hen­it­syn de­clared in a 1974 es­say that he is­sued as he was be­ing ex­iled from the So­viet Union. He was too fa­mous to im­prison or kill, fa­mous for his books, es­pe­cially “The Gu­lag Archipelago” about the com­mu­nist re­gime’s ex­ten­sive sys­tem of prison camps, and for the Nobel Prize awarded to him in 1970. Even as bru­tal a re­gime as the So­viet one didn’t want to be more in­ter­na­tion­ally de­spised than it was al­ready.

He’d re­fused to live by the So­viet lie, which cost him years in some of the worst pris­ons on the planet, and when he was out of prison con­stant ha­rass­ment and abuse, and the con­tin­u­ous threat of go­ing back to prison. And then when the So­vi­ets wanted to be done with him, he lost his home­land. He wanted to stay in Rus­sia, as hard as his life was there.

He was a hero, who prob­a­bly lied less in his life than a typ­i­cal pol­i­ti­cian lies in a day. In one no­ta­ble case, in an hour. His in­sight applies not just to to­tal­i­tar­ian states but to demo­cratic ones. To our story of the first Thanks­giv­ing, for ex­am­ple.

Vi­olence needs lies

Advertise with us

The So­viet re­gime lied both to jus­tify it­self and to make its life eas­ier. “Vi­olence has noth­ing to cover it­self with but lies, and lies can only per­sist through vi­o­lence,” Solz­hen­it­syn wrote.

On the one hand, the bru­tal want to look (most of the time) kind. On the other, rul­ing’s eas­ier if peo­ple ac­cept un­truths — at least live as if they do — than if the state must force them to obey. A totalitarian re­gime wants to look like a gen­tle shep­herd — ex­cept when it needs to re­mind ev­ery­one it’s re­ally a wolf — and it wants its sheep to look like trust­ing sheep.

The state “de­mands of us only a sub­mis­sion to lies, a daily par­tic­i­pa­tion in de­ceit,” Solz­hen­it­syn ex­plained. As a fa­mous So­viet-era joke went: “They pre­tend to pay me and I pre­tend to work.” That state could only fall if peo­ple stopped speak­ing as if they be­lieved it.

Solz­hen­it­syn said no to the whole sys­tem. “Our way must be: Never know­ingly sup­port lies!” he said (the ital­ics are his).

He made this con­crete with a list of nine ways the hon­est per­son would not lie. The good man “will not write, sign, nor pub­lish in any way, a sin­gle line dis­tort­ing, so far as he can see, the truth,” for ex­am­ple. He will walk out of any event when some­one says “a lie, ide­o­log­i­cal drivel, or shame­less pro­pa­ganda” and he will not lie, even in a lit­tle way, to pro­tect or ad­vance him­self.

Advertise with us

Rec­og­niz­ing our lies

Rec­og­niz­ing a lie was easy for Solz­hen­it­syn. If the state said it, it was al­most cer­tainly a lie. Or if true, an in­con­se­quen­tial truth.

But it’s not as easy for us. Some of our found­ing sto­ries are ba­si­cally true. But oth­ers aren’t. Any state, even a gen­er­ally demo­cratic one, wants peo­ple to be­lieve some lies be­cause it wants them to live a cer­tain way, and live that way willingly.

So­ci­et­ies naturally cre­ate self-jus­ti­fy­ing myths. When, for example, their founding and growth included a lot of cruelty and theft and even murder, which upset the preferred image of the new nation as a kind of Garden of Eden.

We’re com­ing up on one of our na­tion’s most im­por­tant found­ing sto­ries. It’s the story of dif­fer­ent peo­ple be­com­ing friends, of the stron­ger wel­com­ing and help­ing the weaker, and both com­ing to­gether over a feast to thank their gods for all the good things they have, in­clud­ing each other. And it’s more a lie than a truth.

Advertise with us

The commonly told story

This is the story as it’s still com­monly told. “The myth is that friendly In­di­ans, un­iden­ti­fied by tribe, wel­come the Pil­grims to Amer­ica, teach them how to live in this new place, sit down to din­ner with them and then dis­ap­pear,” says his­to­rian David Sil­ver­man in an in­ter­view in The Smith­so­nian.

“They hand off Amer­ica to white peo­ple so they can cre­ate a great na­tion ded­i­cated to lib­erty, op­por­tu­nity and Chris­ti­an­ity for the rest of the world to profit. That’s the story — it’s about Na­tive peo­ple con­ced­ing to co­lo­nial­ism. It’s blood­less.”

Sil­ver­man ex­plains that the story of the din­ner be­came an im­por­tant story at the end of the 19th cen­tury. He ar­gues that the story jus­ti­fied the white Prot­es­tant su­prem­acy in the face of grow­ing num­bers of Cath­o­lic and Jew­ish im­mi­grants. It also showed the found­ing as an act of friendship and sep­a­rated it from the uncomfortable realities of slav­ery and the oppression of people who got here first.

Ques­tion the nice sto­ries

Advertise with us

How do we live not by our own society’s lies? Learn to ques­tion sto­ries that are too smooth and nice and sen­ti­men­tal, and too sup­port­ive of the way things supposedly were. Read widely and in sources likely to challenge the story.

We can still give thanks for what our ancestors did well, and I think this deep­ens our grat­i­tude by mak­ing sure it’s well-di­rected. We give thanks for what we have, and not for a made-up his­tory we don’t.

David Mills is the as­so­ci­ate ed­i­to­rial page ed­i­tor and col­um­nist for the Pitts­burgh Post-Ga­zette: dmi­lls@post-ga­zette.com. His previous column was “The ‘diabolically disordered clown’ Pope Francis teaches us how to see.” Solzhenitsyn’s essay can be found here and the interview with David Silverman here.