Pope Francis removed the bishop of Tyler, Texas, from office on Saturday, and the conservative wing of the American Catholic Church erupted. Their websites and social media showed a contempt and even hatred for the pope you wouldn’t expect from people who make a big point of their faithfulness to the Church and her tradition.

Bishop Joseph Strickland had become a celebrity as an outspoken defender of the teaching Pope Francis was supposedly denying or undermining. Fame seems to have been bad for him. He eventually went so far as to effectively endorse claims that Francis “has pushed aside the true pope” and someone calling the pope a “diabolically disoriented clown.”

That would be enough to get him removed, but he was reliably reported to have failed as a pastor so much that the bishops who’d inspected his diocese decided he couldn’t continue.

Contempt for the pope

Advertise with us

And holy cow, what contempt these people have for the pope. From the comments on a Facebook post by a Catholic deacon, who’s also a conservative political activist: “There’s nothing more that Francis hates than those who teach the religion of the Saints”; “Red Francis rides again” (that from a once distinguished historian); and “Anything or anyone truly of Jesus Christ is disposed of by the Vatican!”

Others have called him “evil,” “demonic,” and the like. This is typical: “Pray that Pope Francis finds a holy Confessor to help him with his devilish obsession with sodomy.” This, because while holding to the traditional teaching in a way that disappoints liberal Catholics, Francis wants Catholics to love their LGBTQ neighbors as themselves and asks them — this is my reading of his intentions — to extend to gay people the same sympathetic understanding they extend to their own ways of living.

As far as I can tell, the great majority of out and proud conservative American Catholics oppose the pope. (That “American” is important.) Many of Francis’s sane conservative critics have assumed that bad pope Francis removed good bishop Strickland because he was such a voice for the truth. (They don’t seem to think it possible he just failed as a pastor.) Some do trust him.

The church’s teaching, I should say, is really big not just on submission to the pope but on feeling affection for him. Every one of these people’s heroes from the past would be absolutely horrified to see what they say about Pope Francis.

Politics drives it

Advertise with us

So why do they talk like that about Pope Francis? To be fair, they believe that the Catholic Church tells the truth about the world and people need to know that for their own good. They believe it makes a difference in human happiness. And not just in this world, but in the next. They think Francis wants to take away the “hard words” the world needs to hear.

But politics drives a lot of it. Ideologically-driven Americans, on left and right, seem to love feeling persecuted and oppressed, even when they’re not, and conservatives love feeling the world’s going to hell and they, only they, are left fighting for the good. I’m guessing that the bitterest of the pope’s opponents and the Catholic MAGA people overlap about 98%.

You wouldn’t call Francis a perfect pope. He’s a lot more like the rest of us than we want in our leaders. Catholicism doesn’t promise that the pope is competent, a nice human being, or even well-intentioned.

But in his favor, he points the Catholic Church and the world to a different way of living with people, and that means a lot in a way his critics don’t see. He hasn’t substantially changed any teaching. (Again, to the disappointment of liberal Catholics.)

Francis has tried to change the paradigm, the way people see that teaching in relation to the world we live in — the way Einstein looked at the same universe Newton saw and found a different — though not contradictory — way of understanding it. Catholics call this the development of doctrine, and it’s a crucial, though tricky, part of a body living in history.

Advertise with us

He wants Catholics, and everyone else, to break away from the ways we’ve settled in to seeing others and see them from another angle, more completely than we have. In particular, for Catholics, to avoid defining people first by their sexual lives.

Change the paradigm

To see, for example, LGBTQ people not as people defined by living in a way the Catholic Church rejects, so that their loves are merely fornication. But as people whose love is genuine and admirable even if in some way wrongly directed. As people to be brought as close as possible, which means listening to them and serving them before questioning them.

I think of a story he tells in his book “The Name of God is Mercy.” He was a parish priest in Argentina. A single mother with young children could rarely get work and when she couldn’t work, sold her body on the streets. The church gave her food and one Christmas she came to thank him. He asked her if she got the package. “Yes, yes, thank you for that too,” she said. “But I came here today because you never stopped calling me Señora.”

Pope Francis wants us to learn to call everyone, everyone, Señora and Señor. And that’s a lot harder than any of us want to do.

Advertise with us

David Mills is the as­so­ci­ate ed­i­to­rial page ed­i­tor and columnist for the Pitts­burgh Post-Ga­zette: dmi­lls@post-ga­zette.com. His previous column was “Don’t put your trust in princes, even if they're named Rockey or Innamorato.” He also wrote “Pope Francis understands Christianity better than Jordan Peterson.”