“Love is a lie. Love is the biggest fraud ever imposed on mankind," said the thirty-something man at the bar. A small man with a very dark short beard, wearing a black t-shirt, and a black baseball cap on backwards, was ranting to two friends to his left. He proved to be a better man than his theory.

My wife and I had stopped for lunch at a townie place that turned out to be more of a dive bar than it appeared. When we walked in, the three guys at the bar glanced at us, decided we weren’t worth their attention, and went back to their conversation. Not that it was really a conversation. The other two guys may have said 30 words between them the whole time we were there.

Speaking loud enough to dominate the smallish and mostly empty room, the man said, "I'm not misogynist,” which is not a word you expect to hear in a dive bar. “I'm just realistic. It's a chemical response in the brain to" and then he stumbled, because he wanted to say the rude word for copulate but realized that was not what he wanted to say.

A chemical response

Advertise with us

He began again: "Love is a chemical response in the brain that makes you want to carry on your gene pool." He explained this at length, describing our ignorance in thinking being in love a reason to get married. He knew the science. He didn't speak like the usual bar blowhard who's picked up a few lines and ideas, but like someone who'd thought about it.

As I understood it, he'd been recently divorced and his ex-wife got a lot more than he thought she should. He seemed to have been ranting about this for a while. Every so often he yelled "Shots!" and the bartender refilled their glasses. He spoke well. He was not drunk.

One of his friends said "I'm outta here" in a flat voice, so I couldn’t tell if he was just saying goodbye or was tired of the rant. He walked out the door without looking back. The young man continued. The other friend who has said nothing still said nothing.

He spoke mostly in declarations, which he then developed, all of them about the illusion of love or the evils of the way the courts treated him. I didn't get much of it, because my wife and I were eating, and talking, or trying to talk. Here are a few things he said. I’ve cut out the profanities, which he used generously but not creatively.

Men and women

Advertise with us

He now has children with a girlfriend but tells them that he won’t marry their mother. “Not when she can just go down and the state'll give her my house."

"That's the difference between men and women,” he continued. “Women don't build things. You ever see a woman put a block on top of another? Men build things. We build homes. And then women take them."

"Hate gives clarity of purpose. I've never punched anyone in the face out of love. Love's an intoxicant." It keeps you from thinking clearly, he said, and makes you do things you shouldn't do. Like get married.

"I tell my kinds 'I worship the ground you walk on and I'll do everything to help you carry on my genome,' but I tell 'em 'love doesn't exist'." A little later he added, "God don't exist."

"I've killed more people in Afghanistan than most people have seen die in their family." I don't know what prompted that. He then argued, or tried to argue, that most people believe in love because they don't know much about death.

Advertise with us

Another comment whose origin I didn't hear: "That's the difference between communism and capitalism. Only the strong survive. I may only be 5'7" but I'm strong."

Finally, he said, abruptly, "That's it!" and settled his tab. He and his friend walked out the door.

A chemical reaction

Near the beginning, when he'd explained love as a chemical reaction in your brain that drives you to continue your gene pool, he'd started to give a father's love for his children as another example of how unreal love is. I could hear in his voice — I faced away from him — the moment when he realized what he was about to say about his feelings for his children and saw that he couldn't say it, and shifted the sentence away from its natural conclusion.

After a few stumbling sentences trying not to contradict himself but not agree with himself either, he went back to ranting. I wish I had recorded his exact words, because it was a moment when a man who thought he didn't believe in love thought of his children, and realized he did.

David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “What do we do with the Communists?”.