Behind us at our borough fireworks on the 4th of July was a little girl and her dad, she about three in a long gingham dress and white sandals and her hair done in a French braid. Her very thin dad, looking about thirty, wore jeans and a red and blue rugby shirt and the close-cropped beard apparently required of thin men his age.
She was standing, and he squatted behind her the whole time with his arms around her. As every firework went off, she'd say excitedly, "That was my favowut!" Sometimes, "That was my FAVOWUT favowut!" She'd usually try to explain why but always stop to exclaim "That was my favowut!" when the next firework went off.
It's a wonderful time of life when the lovely things come to you so purely and strongly, when you think of nothing else but their beauty, so that everything lovely that comes to you is your favorite, when you can't rank things because everything is perfect.
It was also a typically American scene. A father and daughter enjoying a community event with hundreds of other people, hosted by a small borough for the other (and much wealthier) communities around it, funded by a group of locals who raise money all year round, including the traditional bake sale at community events, coming at the end of a day which began with a parade and featured a small fair in the town park with food from local vendors and hours of music from local musicians.
But not everyone looks at America like that. A tweet I saw, linked to a news story about a sniper shooting people at a parade, declared: “I mean, is there really any more apt distillation of life in America in 2022 than a bunch of patriotic Americans gathering at a 4th of July parade and 6 of them getting randomly mowed down (and 16 of them injured) by gunfire?” (From last year, but I had it to hand, and it’s an example of the kind of thing people say all the time.)
I don't think there's a term for this kind of statement, the polemical generalization that sounds like it says something profound but doesn't. I think most, like this one, are foolish. Not just exaggerated or overstated, but ideologically-pleasing, click-inducing words disconnected from reality. It’s a “Look at me being outraged” kind of statement, written for the crowd to applaud. And it does little and probably no good.
Read More
A "distillation" of "life in the U.S. in 2022"? Really? A country of almost four million square miles, with 330 million people, stretched across six time zones and a great range of cultures, climates, geographies, histories, etc., living in almost 20,000 towns and cities, most of those with populations under 5,000, and more people in unincorporated areas, and an untold number of neighborhoods, of an astonishing diversity of families, histories, religions, interests and passions, commitments, all combining in an also astonishing diversity of institutions.
And the writer, a smart guy who works in academic publishing, thinks this vast amount of human life and experience can be distilled into one kind of event. That the essence of life in America — the defining thing, the thing that points to what the nation truly is, in its heart — is a single violent event enacted by a single vicious individual out of 330 million. Really?
Yes, homicidal gun violence can erupt at any time, any place. But it doesn't. Kindness can erupt at any time, any place. And it does. So can neighborliness, tolerance, patience, cooperation, just getting along to get something done. And those do.
Our little borough had our annual July 4th parade this year as it has every year. Lots of fire trucks from our and neighboring communities, with the firemen throwing candy to the kids, politicians in convertibles, because they insert themselves into everything, old veterans marching in uniform, amateur marching bands, Boy Scouts, Girl Scouts, Cub Scouts, the whole traditional town parade. Everyone enjoyed themselves.
I suspect no one there worried about a sniper, as they would if gun violence were a distillation of life in America. And this is an area with a lot of guns. Maybe a few people stayed home out of fear, but I’m guessing, knowing my borough, not many.
At the parade last year, and I think this year too, the borough set off a quiet area along the route, apparently because an autistic boy lives there. A typical small town in America changed the parade, changed the whole tradition, to take care of one boy. Isn't that a distillation of life in America too? A truer distillation?
Guys making wild sweeping claims on Twitter will never lack applause. They make people feel angry, and good about themselves for feeling angry, but I don’t think they move many to action — because they’re not telling the whole truth, and most people know it, because they went to the parade and the fireworks.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “The Declaration of Independence v. the Supreme Court.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.