Clarence Thomas explained himself, a day after the irreplaceable ProPublica revealed that he’d lived the high life during his summer breaks thanks to billionaire friends. The gifts included a private flight with his wife Ginni from the United States to Indonesia, a nine-day luxury cruise around the islands, and a private flight home.
He explained in a statement that when he started (I assume as a judge), “colleagues and others in the judiciary” told him that he didn’t have to report “this sort of personal hospitality from close personal friends, who did not have business before the court.” He said he’d always tried to do this.
Let’s give him that. He obeyed the letter of the law as he saw it. But that’s just ethical minimalism. A Supreme Court justice needs to do more.
It was all friendship, he said, as did his host. Not politics. “We have never sought to influence Justice Thomas on any legal or political issue,” and neither has anyone they have invited, Harlan Crow said in a statement. He and his wife have funded tributes to the justice, because they believe him “one of the greatest Americans of our time.” But they haven’t tried to influence his decisions.
Some ethics experts disagree with Mr. Thomas’s claim that he didn’t have to report such trips and meals. Mr. Thomas might be right. After all, the ethics laws were created by people — politicians — with an interest in creating laws with ambiguities and wiggle room.
I do wonder if, while sitting in a deck chair on a yacht sailing around Indonesia, drinking some fancy cocktail made with some very expensive liquor, attended to hand and foot, he didn’t hear a little voice saying, “Maybe you should tell people about this?” He had to know there’s a difference between a neighbor giving you a burger and a beer and a man giving you the trip of a lifetime — and doing it almost every year for 20 years.
Read More
His former Supreme Court clerk John Yoo, now a professor at Berkeley Law School, told the New York Times that Mr. Thomas can’t be influenced by such things. He’s the justice to whom “money means the least,” he said, mentioning that he grew up very poor.
I would like to think that’s true. It might be true. The justice — an originalist who believes in natural law — has been consistently conservative in his views as a justice. He’d say, I think, that he only interprets what America’s founding fathers intended and that his work is more fill-in-the-blanks than story-telling. No room for bias there. Maybe he does it that way, however he spends his summers.
I have my doubts, because human beings can’t help but be shaped by the world they choose to live in, and he chose to live, for significant periods of time, in the world of the hyper-wealthy.
As the saying goes, if you lie down with dogs, you’ll wake up with fleas. The opposite is probably just as true. If you dine with billionaires on superyachts, you’ll wake up wanting to continue dining with billionaires on superyachts. You’ll wake up with champagne tastes. And champagne opinions.
But maybe Mr. Thomas survived all the gifts unchanged. It doesn’t matter. The issue isn’t the man he really is, it’s the man he lets America think he is.
Someone entrusted with such power should be sensitive to the way people look at him. He should have known that the average American would wonder about the objectivity of a man who’s gotten so much for so long from such friends. And he should know that as a justice of the Supreme Court, he must do everything he can to show people that he’s as objective and fair and unbiased as humanly possible.
He’s human. He’s just as vulnerable to temptation and corruption as any other human being. As a Catholic, he knows this. The Catholic devotional life offers a continual lesson in how morally vulnerable we are and how easily we fool ourselves. Knowing that, he should do everything he can to allay our reasonable suspicions.
People in positions like his want a private life and not have every friendship and relation scrutinized. Any of us would feel the same way. But someone who accepts a position as one of the most powerful people in America gives up some of his privacy.
That’s the deal. We give you power, you tell us when people give you things. You let us check up on you. If you want to take up a life of public service at that level, you should accept a life of public transparency. Clarence Thomas took the power but not the openness.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Jimmy Carter was a politician we won't see again, and that's a loss for us.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.