Martin Luther King, Jr., is a public hero, one of the few we have, and maybe the most important. That doesn’t mean that everyone listens to him, but it does mean almost everyone wants a piece of him. Everyone wants to claim him as their own. But he’s not everyone’s hero in the same sense.
We shouldn’t appropriate other people’s heroes. As a white American, I can say he’s mine. But he’s not mine in the sense that he belongs to Black Americans. He came from the same community, and they share more with him than I do, not least the experience of bigotry and the cost of resisting it.
The public hero is someone of whom you can say with almost anyone, “He said this” and your hearers will recognize his authority. They may well disagree with him, but they can’t blow off your appeal.
Which in King’s case is not as it once was. The conservative magazine National Review, the standard-bearer of the mainstream right, now celebrates him and makes a point of publishing an article on his day.
But in March 1965, the editors called Mr. King and his colleagues “highminded, self-righteous ‘children of light,’” men of “rabble-rousing demagoguery” who “taught anarchy and chaos by word and deed.” The racial strife of the day was entirely their fault. The magazine’s editors did not see, I think refused to see, the obvious fact of racism and the suffering of fellow Americans.
That helps explain why we shouldn’t appropriate someone else’s heroes. By ignoring those who have a better claim to know what the hero meant and what he means today, you make him safe for you — meaning you you keep yourself from learning everything you can from someone you claim as a hero.
Read More
You can’t say someone’s your hero too without saying who he is. To say who the hero is, we naturally pick the characteristics most useful to us as if they defined him. You just don’t claim someone as your own, you claim that he basically agrees with you.
It’s very hard not to do that with heroes. The Jesus many Christians believe in, for example, doesn’t look exactly like the one in the gospels. He looks a little too American. He’s safer.
Genuine heroes, like Martin Luther King, Jr., should be engaged as a whole, on the assumption that as heroes, they’re bigger than you. Maybe they saw something you don’t, or that you don’t want to see. You can’t be sure you’re more open to some truths than were National Review’s editors to the reality of racism.
King himself said something like this. Being compassionate and non-violent, he told an anti-war group in 1967, “helps us to see the enemy’s point of view, to hear his questions, to know his assessment of ourselves. For from his view we may indeed see the basic weaknesses of our own condition, and if we are mature we may learn and grow and profit from the wisdom of the brothers who are called the opposition.”
The white Americans’ King is the one who wrote “Letter From a Birmingham Jail” and gave the “I have a dream/content of their character” speech. He spoke of the ideal of a color-blind society. That’s not wrong. There is that side of King.
But there are others, like the one who continued fighting racism, who said near the end of his life that “America is still a racist country. Racism still stands at the center of so much of our nation.”
There’s the radically non-violent side, for another. In accepting the Nobel Peace Prize in 1964, he called nonviolence “the answer to the crucial political and moral question of our time — the need for man to overcome oppression and violence without resorting to violence and oppression. Civilization and violence are antithetical concepts.”
And the religious side, for a fourth. “All that I do in civil rights, I do because I consider it part of my ministry,” he said. “I have no other ambitions in life but to achieve excellence in the Christian ministry. I don’t plan to run for any political office. I don’t plan to do anything but remain a preacher.”
And the politically radical side, for a fifth. In his 1967 “Where Do We Go From Here?” speech, he called for “restructuring the whole of American society. There are forty million poor people here, and one day we must ask the question, ‘Why are there forty million poor people in America?’” He also strongly opposed the war in Viet Nam.
At least one side is likely to challenge most of us. I’m not hugely fond of radical non-violence myself, because I’d have to live like that — no sharp verbal attacks on my enemies, for one thing — and I don’t want to. But because I claim Martin Luther King, Jr., as a hero, I have to ask if he’s right.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. He can be reached at dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “Scrooge and Mr. Potter wage the real war on Christmas.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.