Sometimes, with only a few syllables, people inadvertently, or purposefully, reveal what they really think, where they really stand. The unveiling gives food for thought.
So it was with an account of Billy Graham’s funeral, two words of which linger in my mind on the brink of Holy Week and Passover. These two words are “exclusivist” and “insisted.”
These words in turn revived, as a kind of counterpoint, an address Bishop Desmond Tutu made in Pittsburgh a decade ago.
The more recent first: At the Rev. Graham’s funeral, his son Franklin Graham “did not veer into politics,” The New York Times noted, “[b]ut he did include the kind of explicit, exclusivist claim of Christian faith that he has consistently used in his public appearances, including presidential inaugurations, when he insisted on giving his prayer ‘in the name of Jesus’.”
I am not sure why the above needed to be stated (as opposed to just quoting the speaker). It is, after all, not unexpected that a Christian minister would mention the Christian Gospel at a Christian evangelist’s funeral.
But to say someone “insisted” on something is to imply disagreement. The insistence runs counter to the writer’s intellectual bent or sense of good taste, or the action insisted upon marks a departure from accepted practice. And, bizarrely, what was allegedly “insisted” upon took place at a presidential inauguration, not the funeral at hand.
The reader gets to draw his or her own conclusions about a writer’s viewpoint, but historical facts, easily established via transcripts and YouTube, cannot be argued with:
Myrlie Evers-Williams, widow of slain civil rights champion Medgar Evers, concluded her prayer at Barack Obama’s 2013 inauguration “in Jesus’ name, in the name of all who are holy and right we pray, Amen.”
In 2009, the Rev. Rick Warren prayed “in the name of the One who changed my life — Yeshua, Isa, Jésus, Jesus…”
The Rev. Kirbyjon Caldwell said, in 2005, “Respecting persons of all faiths, I humbly submit this prayer in the name of Jesus Christ” and in 2001, “in the name that’s above all other names, Jesus, the Christ.”
Also at George W. Bush’s 2001 inauguration, Franklin Graham concluded almost exactly as his father had at Bill Clinton’s 1993 inauguration: “In the name of the Father, and of the Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, and of the Holy Spirit.”
Christians tend to pray in the name of Christ. Interestingly, the last president to have a non-Christian religious leader, a rabbi, pray at his inauguration — until Donald Trump — was Ronald Reagan.
I welcome the return of multi-faith prayer to bless our nation’s leaders and milestones, for two reasons. One, because this is a nation of diverse faiths, a fact that should be demonstrated in order to preserve the separation of church (or synagogue or mosque) and state.
And two, because anyone who struggles with finding truth to live by must grapple with other faiths’ “exclusivist claims,” and it is good to be reminded of that. We are reminded when others “insist” on praying and speaking freely from within their faith.
Yes, real and vibrant Christianity is and always has been exclusivist, as is every claim to truth ever made. The word “true” implies “not true.” Right implies wrong. Even taking the position that many truths may be simultaneously true is to assert a truth and to invite challenge. It is inescapable.
But that doesn’t mean the answer to every proposition is necessarily either/or. It may be “yes/and.” Contradictory ideas may be simultaneously true. We call it “paradox,” and Christianity happens to be rife with them: Jesus was fully man yet fully God, to really live as myself I must die to myself, and so on.
It causes discomfort, doesn’t it? Great discomfort, even to those who profess to embrace it.
When Bishop Tutu visited Pittsburgh in 2007, he scoffed at the notion that only those who believe in Jesus can enter heaven. “Can you imagine that there are those who think God is a Christian?” he asked, to his audience’s appreciative chuckles.
That’s a shocking misrepresentation, or denial, of Christian teaching. Christians don’t believe that God is a Christian but that Jesus Christ was, and is, God. And the Gospel of John asserts it was Jesus who said, “No one comes to the Father except through me” — an exclusivist claim if ever there was one.
Embracing our respective faiths inevitably creates divides, and to avoid them, some may alter their faith. But life need not be exclusionary. Civility, which is love at work between those who disagree, can hold us together no matter where we are in life’s struggle. If you have read to this point, I thank you for struggling with me.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.