Talk­ing with the peo­ple at the front lines of the Pitts­burgh Cli­mate Ac­tion Plan, I flashed on the de­fend­ers of the Alamo.

The lo­cals know they have no re­al­is­tic shot at meet­ing the flat-out crazy nu­meric bench­marks in re­duc­ing pol­lu­tion in the next de­cade, any more than the Tex­ans had of hold­ing the fort. Yet there’s no thought of hoist­ing the white flag.

Here’s an ex­am­ple from The Plan: “Decrease drive alone com­mute trips by 50 per­cent by 2030.”

I mean, come on. I stood on the Fort Duquesne Bridge at 3 p.m. Wed­nes­day af­ter­noon, count­ing south­bound cars in the west­ern lane head­ing to the Fort Pitt Bridge and Tun­nel. Rush hour al­ready had slowed ve­hi­cles to a speed that made it easy to see who was trav­el­ing one to a car and who wasn’t.

Advertise with us

In a span of seven min­utes, I tal­lied 72 sin­gle-per­son cars, 13 two-per­son rides and seven with more than two. Once I re­crossed the Al­le­gheny River to the of­fice, I could watch as cars re­li­ably backed up all the way to Heinz Field by 4.

That’s the way this re­gion, and much of Amer­ica, is set up. Nearly all those folks crawl­ing to­ward the Park­way West don’t live in places with good pub­lic trans­por­ta­tion op­tions, and there is pre­cious lit­tle the city can do about their idling on the way through town.

Or how about re­duc­ing “land­fill waste by 90 per­cent by 2030”? Or “elim­i­nate land­fill emis­sions by 2030”? Or “zero waste,” for the love of plas­tic? Most city parks don’t even have re­cy­cling bins be­side the trash bar­rels.

This is an odd week to be com­plain­ing about the city’s ef­forts, as it began offering free mulch to the city’s gar­den­ers Satur­day, the re­sult of haul­ing away and grind­ing up more than 2,000 Christmas trees that the citizenry dropped off at 10 sites last win­ter. That di­verted more than 21 tons from the land­fill, where it would have been bur­ied and cre­ated meth­ane. So it’s great that the mulch might pro­tect to­ma­toes and erad­i­cate weeds in­stead. The city hopes it has enough mulch to of­fer it free to Pitts­burgh res­i­dents the next three Satur­day morn­ings at the Forestry Division headquarters off Stan­ton Avenue in High­land Park.

But there are are about 115,000 sin­gle-fam­ily homes in Pitts­burgh. If even half of them had Christ­mas trees, that means about 95 per­cent of them were left at the curb last win­ter with the trash.

Advertise with us

Teresa Brad­ley, who be­came the city’s re­cy­cling su­per­vi­sor only a cou­ple of months be­fore the tree-re­trieval pro­gram be­gan, ac­knowl­edges, “All we can do is try to chip away at these things.” She likes the sug­ges­tion of get­ting the word out next Christ­mas sea­son about drop­off sites by con­tact­ing churches and tree ven­dors be­fore­hand.

As for pair­ing re­cy­cling bins with trash cans in ev­ery park, the city is seek­ing grants to do more of that. But such ef­forts of­ten go awry. Re­cy­cling con­tain­ers on the South Side get filled with trash be­cause a lot of peo­ple don’t un­der­stand or care that pizza plates and cof­fee cups don’t be­long there.

“There’s no money in re­cy­cling un­less it’s source-sep­a­rated,” Ms. Brad­ley said. “They’re com­mod­i­ties. We need to start treat­ing them as com­mod­i­ties.” Oth­er­wise, the ex­er­cise of re­cy­cling is a cha­rade.

To that end, the city is seek­ing state fund­ing to dis­trib­ute 13,000 35-gal­lon re­cy­cling bins to res­i­dents over the next two years. That would nearly tri­ple the num­ber of big blue bins out there, and elim­i­nate more of those blue plas­tic gro­cery bags that can muck up what’s valu­able in the sin­gle-stream sys­tem. But even if 20,000 res­i­den­tial bins wind up around town, about five of six city house­holds would be with­out one.

There is good news. Grant Ervin, Pitts­burgh’s chief resilience of­fi­cer, points to U.S. Cen­sus data that Bike Pitts­burgh col­lected, show­ing Pitts­burgh is tied with San Fran­cisco for the third high­est per­cent­age of res­i­dents who walk to work. We’re at 11.1 per­cent, be­hind only Boston and Wash­ing­ton. About 2 per­cent of res­i­dents bike to work, 12th high­est in the coun­try and twice the per­cent­age of a de­cade ago.

Advertise with us

That’s hap­pened be­cause the av­er­age age has skewed younger re­cently in densely pop­u­lated neigh­bor­hoods such as Law­renceville, the Strip Dis­trict and the North Side, all close to jobs cen­ters. Their prop­erty and wage taxes have helped the city put in bike lanes and pave a lot of other streets, too.

None of that means the city can come close to shav­ing its car­bon foot­print by as much as it seeks. Mayor Bill Peduto, in his throwdown with President Donald Trump about stick­ing to the Paris cli­mate ac­cords, has a tougher hill to climb than Canton Avenue in Beechview.

Still, even small bites have mer­its of their own. Plenty of city gar­dens need mulch.

Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-ga­zette or 412-263-1947 or Twit­ter @broth­er­oneill