Talking with the people at the front lines of the Pittsburgh Climate Action Plan, I flashed on the defenders of the Alamo.
The locals know they have no realistic shot at meeting the flat-out crazy numeric benchmarks in reducing pollution in the next decade, any more than the Texans had of holding the fort. Yet there’s no thought of hoisting the white flag.
Here’s an example from The Plan: “Decrease drive alone commute trips by 50 percent by 2030.”
I mean, come on. I stood on the Fort Duquesne Bridge at 3 p.m. Wednesday afternoon, counting southbound cars in the western lane heading to the Fort Pitt Bridge and Tunnel. Rush hour already had slowed vehicles to a speed that made it easy to see who was traveling one to a car and who wasn’t.
In a span of seven minutes, I tallied 72 single-person cars, 13 two-person rides and seven with more than two. Once I recrossed the Allegheny River to the office, I could watch as cars reliably backed up all the way to Heinz Field by 4.
That’s the way this region, and much of America, is set up. Nearly all those folks crawling toward the Parkway West don’t live in places with good public transportation options, and there is precious little the city can do about their idling on the way through town.
Read More
Or how about reducing “landfill waste by 90 percent by 2030”? Or “eliminate landfill emissions by 2030”? Or “zero waste,” for the love of plastic? Most city parks don’t even have recycling bins beside the trash barrels.
This is an odd week to be complaining about the city’s efforts, as it began offering free mulch to the city’s gardeners Saturday, the result of hauling away and grinding up more than 2,000 Christmas trees that the citizenry dropped off at 10 sites last winter. That diverted more than 21 tons from the landfill, where it would have been buried and created methane. So it’s great that the mulch might protect tomatoes and eradicate weeds instead. The city hopes it has enough mulch to offer it free to Pittsburgh residents the next three Saturday mornings at the Forestry Division headquarters off Stanton Avenue in Highland Park.
But there are are about 115,000 single-family homes in Pittsburgh. If even half of them had Christmas trees, that means about 95 percent of them were left at the curb last winter with the trash.
Teresa Bradley, who became the city’s recycling supervisor only a couple of months before the tree-retrieval program began, acknowledges, “All we can do is try to chip away at these things.” She likes the suggestion of getting the word out next Christmas season about dropoff sites by contacting churches and tree vendors beforehand.
As for pairing recycling bins with trash cans in every park, the city is seeking grants to do more of that. But such efforts often go awry. Recycling containers on the South Side get filled with trash because a lot of people don’t understand or care that pizza plates and coffee cups don’t belong there.
“There’s no money in recycling unless it’s source-separated,” Ms. Bradley said. “They’re commodities. We need to start treating them as commodities.” Otherwise, the exercise of recycling is a charade.
To that end, the city is seeking state funding to distribute 13,000 35-gallon recycling bins to residents over the next two years. That would nearly triple the number of big blue bins out there, and eliminate more of those blue plastic grocery bags that can muck up what’s valuable in the single-stream system. But even if 20,000 residential bins wind up around town, about five of six city households would be without one.
There is good news. Grant Ervin, Pittsburgh’s chief resilience officer, points to U.S. Census data that Bike Pittsburgh collected, showing Pittsburgh is tied with San Francisco for the third highest percentage of residents who walk to work. We’re at 11.1 percent, behind only Boston and Washington. About 2 percent of residents bike to work, 12th highest in the country and twice the percentage of a decade ago.
That’s happened because the average age has skewed younger recently in densely populated neighborhoods such as Lawrenceville, the Strip District and the North Side, all close to jobs centers. Their property and wage taxes have helped the city put in bike lanes and pave a lot of other streets, too.
None of that means the city can come close to shaving its carbon footprint by as much as it seeks. Mayor Bill Peduto, in his throwdown with President Donald Trump about sticking to the Paris climate accords, has a tougher hill to climb than Canton Avenue in Beechview.
Still, even small bites have merits of their own. Plenty of city gardens need mulch.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.