Gov. Tom Wolf’s announcement last week that the state is looking into better train service between Pittsburgh and Altoona could be good news if you live in Altoona, or Greensburg, Latrobe or Johnstown.
But it’s hard to see how it gets Pittsburgh any closer to its long-time goal of more trains to Harrisburg, Philadelphia and New York.
Pittsburgh has just one morning train east now, and one evening train coming back. That’s The Pennsylvanian, with New York the final and most popular stop. More than 220,000 riders get on and off it somewhere each year despite it being excruciatingly slow with seven stops across five and a half hours between Pittsburgh and Harrisburg. That’s in stark contrast to the 14 fast, daily trains running in each direction on dedicated track between Harrisburg and Philadelphia.
Pittsburgh hasn’t been expecting equity for our 1.8 million people within 25 miles of the Downtown station, but Mayor Bill Peduto asked state Transportation Secretary Leslie Richards three years ago for at least one more stinkin’ train — and preferably two — to New York.
J.J. Abbott, spokesman for Gov. Wolf, said the level of interest in a commuter train between Altoona and Pittsburgh should tell the Department of Transportation something about the longer run. That’s dubious.
A morning train out of Altoona and an evening train back might be a good idea on its own, though just such a train failed in the early 1980s, not attracting enough customers to last even two years. It might be different now, with WiFi allowing commuters to work as they ride.
PennDOT and its paid consultant, Anna Lynn Smith of WSP in suburban Philadelphia, say this $200,000 study is focused only on demand within the 117 miles between Pittsburgh and Altoona. She believes it’s there because she’s seen a passenger rail renaissance in the east, which includes the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority extending commuter train service in Delaware County all the way to Wawa (a stop that has to be fun for the conductors to shout).
“We’re going to look at what makes sense from a startup perspective,’’ Ms. Smith said. A couple of weeks into it, she’s finding ample census data on commutes in Western Pennsylvania. Prior studies have looked at infrastructure improvements on the line, which is owned by Norfolk Southern. Sidings could be built to allow a freight train to pass a passenger train, or vice versa. Anything that adds speed seems a must; The Pennsylvanian takes 2 hours and 46 minutes to get from Altoona to Pittsburgh, and 57 minutes to get in from Greensburg.
And then there’s the question of where daily commuters would go from the Amtrak station on Liberty Avenue near 11th Street. In 2007, the Port Authority shut down its limited-service spur line from the Steel Plaza subway stop to its station at the Martin Luther King Jr. East Busway. That’s a two-minute walk from the Amtrak station. Reopening the subway shuttle for morning and evening train commuters could be part of an upcoming system-wide assessment, a Port Authority spokesman said.
PennDOT says this commuter train wouldn’t necessarily be an Amtrak operation. Virginia Railway Express in Northern Virginia has contracted with a private operator since 2010, the New Mexico Rail Runner Express is privately run, and Brightline trains began running in South Florida this year. Any new Altoona-Pittsburgh trains wouldn’t really be competing with Amtrak, but Amtrak could bid on the project itself.
A Norfolk Southern spokesman said it’s open to discussing more passenger trains on its line, but they’d have to operate without delaying the 40 to 60 daily freight trains on the railway’s “Premiere Corridor’’ between New York and Chicago. They also mustn’t hinder route maintenance. The railroad also would need to be paid. You might deduce it’s not an eager partner.
Mark Spada, president of Western Pennsylvanians for Passenger Rail, said his group is happy Gov. Wolf is interested in improving rail travel for Western Pennsylvanians — but this can’t be the last step. Lucinda Beattie of Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership said the goal still has to be better connections between Pennsylvania’s two largest cities.
The track record (puns always intended) isn’t good here. “The Fort Pitt’’ train stopped less than two years of runs from Altoona to Pittsburgh in January 1983 because only 30 passengers rode it daily. PennDOT paid Amtrak $547,000 to operate it, according to a contemporary PG account. That would be $1.4 million today. You could repave better than a third of a mile of the Parkway East with that.
“It makes you wonder why we are doing it again,’’ Ms. Beattie said.
The governor from the part of the state with great train service is looking this way, at long last. He needs to look harder.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.