Let’s flip all the cards and declare, four months into the year, that there will be no better indicator of America going nuts than the announcement that the Outing Club at Penn State is no longer allowed to go outside.
Yep, that’s it. Look no further. The Apathy Club may disband for lack of interest and the Procrastinators Club may never get around to meeting, but nothing can beat the university’s “assessment of risk management” determining that the ominous threat of ow-ees and boo-boos is too great for young adults to go into the woods unsupervised.
Mind you, this is not because anyone was getting hurt. This was done because one can easily imagine the dangers when groups of self-supervised students are permitted to go hiking, canoeing, kayaking, trail-building and camping. And imagine, administrators did.
This was a “proactive risk assessment” which is what bureaucrats say when they mean it’s not based on anything that actually happened. Among the perceived dangers are — get this — outdoorsmen and outdoorswomen being in places with poor cellphone service.
Humans camped for roughly 2.8 million years without cellphones. The Penn State Outing Club began 98 years ago, and you need not be a history major to know they camped for nearly all of that time without cellphones. But that is evidently not adequate precedent.
More than Lyme disease or falling rocks, a university’s biggest fear is other people’s lawyers. The risk assessment office at Penn State made its decision without giving the members of the Outing Club a chance to present their case. Club leaders talked to the faculty adviser and university staff about the safety issues, but had no direct contact with the risk assessment office that made this decision.
Read More
The Outing Club has an online petition to keep it at the university, and it had more than 2,200 signatures early Wednesday afternoon. It uses the jargon of our time — “PSOC has allowed students to feel safe and heard” — but perhaps they could be a little more direct. Something like the following might be in order:
Look, a lot of us were raised by helicopter parents. We couldn’t go outside without them setting up play dates for us. We weren’t allowed to walk to school like previous generations had. None of us knocked on a friend’s door to see if they wanted to come out and play; we texted them. Always.
Some of us have never even chosen up sides; there was generally an adult with a whistle around his neck, whether real or metaphorical, whenever and wherever we played.
But now we’re young adults. We’re old enough to serve in the armed forces. We’re old enough to vote and to have a credit card. Some of us can even rent cars. We find we like being on our own. Some of us have even learned to go off into the woods and go a whole weekend without a smart phone.
OK, so maybe not the whole weekend, but the parts when we’re deep in the woods, yeah, we’ve learned to be OK for a while even when completely unplugged.
Anyway, this is a university. It’s supposed to be preparing us for life on the outside. We ought to learn how to survive outside before we graduate, shouldn’t we?
Penn State said part of its decision for disbanding the Outing Club and others was because of “misuse of alcohol,” but student leaders of all three clubs denied allegations of drinking. If some of these students enjoyed a beer in a tent, they’d hardly be the first, but the president of The Outing Club said dry trips were better for club culture. Besides, if you’re lugging a 40-pound backpack into the woods, you don’t want to be towing a cooler, too.
The university and its clubs are still discussing all this, but it doesn’t seem likely that there will be any going back to the way things were for 98 years.
So until a firehouse burns down or there’s a drought in Waterville, the Penn State Outing Club not being allowed to go outside is the odds-on favorite for Irony of the Year.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.