It’s like a game of chicken on the railroad tracks, with neither North Siders nor the Norfolk Southern close to giving way.
My column Sunday highlighted the railroad’s plan to send double-stacked trains down its four tracks in the deep, walled gulch that slices through Allegheny Commons Park. The only way to provide enough clearance for taller trains is to raise the overpasses at Pennsylvania Avenue and North Avenue/Brighton Road, the railroad says.
The Northside Leadership Conference can’t help but notice that raising the roadways there would put them above some doorways. It’s also none too keen on having even more trains come chugging through the park, more visibly and more loudly. It suggests lowering the tracks — “undercutting,” in railroad vernacular — to lessen the impact. It at least wants a more detailed explanation of why that can’t be done.
The railroad, meantime, is saying its $1 million-plus contribution for a new pedestrian bridge over the tracks in the park — a walking route that lasted a century before the old bridge went out in 2002 — hinges on everything else going its way.
“We volunteered to include [the pedestrian bridge money] in the project to take some of the sting out of what is going to occur at North Avenue,” Norfolk Southern spokesman Rudy Husband wrote in an email. “It would be logical to conclude that if the clearance project doesn’t occur, the pedestrian bridge won’t occur either.”
John DeSantis, on the North Side conference’s bridge committee, said it has tried and failed on three occasions to get the railroad to commit in writing to the pedestrian bridge funding. Nobody saw that as a lock even if everything went Norfolk Southern’s way. Jerry Green, a Mexican War Streets resident, dismissed the proposed contribution as “shut up and sit down” money.
Norfolk Southern train
Stepping way back from the particular problems of this terrain, we’re at this point because Americans require a lot of stuff. More frequently, we like that stuff delivered right to our doors. Nobody can move stuff like the railroads. One of these double-stacked trains can take as many as 300 tractor-trailers off the roads. Norfolk Southern would save time — and big money — by rerouting the tall trains it currently runs on the southern side of the Monongahela and western side of the Ohio before crossing the Ohio at Brunot Island to rejoin the main line downriver.
The pressure to increase bridge clearance isn’t coming entirely from the railroads. It’s state policy to have 22-foot clearance on all new overpasses. Twenty-five years ago, when this rail line was still owned by Conrail, the commonwealth and that railroad signed contracts to spend $80 million to raise bridges and lower track further east. All that was designed to help the Port of Philadelphia, with the customarily inflated promises of tens of thousands of new transportation and distribution jobs.
Now that the Panama Canal has doubled its tonnage capacity, East Coast ports all expect more cargo to be coming in and, ultimately, to be transported by the nation’s trains and trucks.
Norfolk Southern has a 2009 engineering report from URS Corp. that says Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority sewers run parallel to and under the track bed, and behind the 20-foot high retaining wall on the eastern side. Track lowering would take six feet of material from the face of the walls and undermine them, URS said, though there are ways to mitigate that. It presented no cost estimates.
Glenn Olcerst, a retired lawyer in the Mexican War Streets, has been saying since 2011 that this process was flawed from the get-go. All the railroad overpasses on this short stretch should have been considered together from the start. The city and railroad looked at raising the West Ohio Street Bridge in isolation, which gave them more leverage to build in a historic park, Mr. Olcerst said. (That bridge shut down in January, and its replacement is the better part of two years away, causing daily traffic headaches for detoured commuters.)
In all, these bridge projects to allow double-stacked trains amount to a “constructive taking” and “diminishment in perpetuity of a historic landmark,” Mr. Olcerst wrote in a recent mass email. The railroad “should be made to pay for less intrusive alternatives,” he said, and he’s urging the Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy to go to court to stop the raising of the North Avenue Bridge.
If there’s anything more American than moving tons of consumer goods around, it’s litigation.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.