North Side residents, upset about Norfolk Southern Railways’ plan to raise the height of two bridges, went into a meeting with the railroad last week with a goal of bringing state and city officials to their side.
They succeeded.
State Transportation Secretary Leslie S. Richards said Monday that her department will spend the next three or four months reviewing the project to consider other options, including a hybrid plan that would lower the track a little and raise the bridges a little. The railroad says the work needs to be done so it can route double-stack container cars through the North Side.
Ms. Richards also said she was unhappy with the open-house format of the meeting and would require a more formal presentation in the future.
In addition, Dan Gilman, Mayor Bill Peduto’s chief of staff, said in an email to residents that the railroad has had “minimal” involvement with the city about the project and that the mayor has told the railroad of his “sincere frustration” with last week’s meeting. He said many residents complained that they “left feeling more confused and more disenfranchised” by the meeting.
And state Rep. Jake Wheatley, D-Hill District, held a conference call last week with Ms. Richards to express his concerns.
Read More
“We’re going to take a few months and look at what other options there are,” Ms. Richards said Monday. “We hope to get back to them in late summer or early fall.”
Norfolk Southern Railroad Public Forum
The railroad received a $20 million grant from PennDOT in April 2017 to upgrade 14 bridges throughout Allegheny County, including three on the North Side. It presented plans for the full range of changes last week in the basement of the Children’s Museum, including the options for raising bridges at Pennsylvania and West North avenues and lowering the track bed at Columbus Avenue.
Rudy Husband, the railroad’s vice president for government relations in Pennsylvania, said it is less expensive to raise the bridges than it is to lower the tracks and the railroad applied for the grant specifically to raise the bridges. It generally costs five or six times more to lower tracks, he said.
“The grant was for work to be done in a specific way,” said Mr. Husband, who added that he had not heard of the hybrid suggestion before. “That would change the economics completely,” he said.
The railroad has said the project would allow it to increase the trains through the North Side from 20 to 25 a day to 40 to 50 a day after it shifted some double-stack trains from the current, longer route through the South Side. The railroad is using $8.6 million of its own money on the project.
The format for last week’s meeting, which displayed plans at various points along the project and had railroad representatives available to answer individual questions, had been approved by the city and PennDOT in advance, Mr. Husband said. But when double the expected crowd attended — as part of a campaign by North Side groups who handed out stickers to residents to show their displeasure with various aspects of the project — “things could have been a little smoother,” he conceded.
Mr. Wheatley said he’s glad PennDOT is doing an additional review of the project. The agency has hired consultant Johnson, Mirmiran & Thompson Inc.
“I’m very happy [PennDOT is] open to looking at alternatives,” he said. “I don’t know what the right solution is. I would hope all involved would look at any and all suitable solutions.”
Glenn Olcerst, a Central North Side resident who’s among those against the project, said he is encouraged that officials are paying attention to some of the residents’ concerns but urged them to keep up the pressure. Officials also need to review other aspects such as air pollution and possible disruption to historic Allegheny Commons park, he said.
“This is better than nothing,” he said. “But it’s way short of what it’s going to take to satisfy people here.”
Ed Blazina: eblazihna@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.