With Allegheny County executives suggesting that some of its 130 municipalities might want to dissolve, I thought I’d resurrect an old song.
See if you can channel your inner dancing Austrian and sing these next few lines to the tune of Julie Andrews’ “My Favorite Things.”
Pittsburgh’s the largest and Haysville’s the leastest
Findlay is westest and Plum is our eastest
Rhyming communities this way is dumb
But who in this county can name every one?
Read More
OK, there’s more, but let’s stop there. Some of you are already going to be stuck with that earworm all day.
I wrote a longer version of the song seven years ago when I came across an online game where the player tries to name all 130 municipalities in Allegheny County in 12 minutes. I’m not pulling your Wilmerding. The game exists in two versions, before and after the 2010 census.

When I checked sporcle.com this week, the games had been played more than 2,000 times between them. Incredibly, 3 to 5 percent of the players could name all 130, and I suspect all of them are Mark Wolosik, manager of the county Elections Division, unwinding on his lunch hour.
Anyway, the last three county executives — Rich Fitzgerald, Dan Onorato and Jim Roddey — who also happen to be the only three county executives, got together earlier this month to pitch a disincorporation plan. It would be strictly voluntary, and this would be the only county in Pennsylvania with the ability, assuming America’s Largest Full-Time State Legislature finds the time to give the OK.
For those who might be new to The County With More Police Departments Than Montana, let me explain why this measure is worth a look.
There are two kinds of residents in Allegheny County, those who live in big places and those who live in itsy-bitsy ones. With nearly half the county’s population living in its 12 largest municipalities (and nearly half of those in Pittsburgh), the big/small split is almost down the middle, even if our map looks like a quilting bee run amok.
Ninety-nine of our municipalities have fewer than 10,000 people, 72 have fewer than 5,000 souls and 14 places cannot scrape up even 1,000 carbon-based bipeds. That’s not necessarily a bad thing. It’s good to be the mayor, or to be able to call the mayor, and it’s particularly easy if she’s sitting next to you on the couch.
But most of these municipal lines were drawn up generations ago for an economy that no longer exists. Mr. Fitzgerald believes the county could offer better services to the disincorporated without any increase in municipal taxes, and some who govern the smallest communities will welcome another tool in the governmental toolbox.
Amy Markel is one of seven council members for the 88 households in Glenfield, a community of 205 living within a highway-divided square mile along the Ohio River — and that gives Glenfield almost three times as many residents as neighboring Haysville, with 70.
Ms. Markel ran for council in 2015 because more young families had moved to Glenfield and she wanted, among other things, a better playground for her 9-year-old son and his new friends. Glenfield just got a grant for that playground, and the new council also launched curbside recycling this year.
But residents still rely on septic tanks rather than a sewage system, get water service through neighboring Aleppo and rely on state police for protection. So, yes, she’d be open to hearing what services the county could offer.
Thirty-eight other states allow disincorporation. This being Pennsylvania, no referendum launched by the citizenry could make that happen here. Under this proposal, the municipality’s governing body would need to vote to put disincorporation on the ballot. If the citizenry then approved it, the plan would go to county council.
A place wouldn’t lose its identity if it disincorporated. People say they live in Wexford and that’s just a post office. Lawrenceville stopped being an independent borough in 1868 but it remains a proudly distinct neighborhood in Pittsburgh.
Mr. Fitzgerald is right when he says a citizen’s sense of community is more likely to come from churches, Little Leagues, playgrounds and neighborhood bakeries than from the address on the tax bill.
Even if one or two municipalities dissolve themselves, there will still be no county quite like Allegheny.Illinois’ Cook County (Chicago’s turf) narrowly tops us with 132 municipalities, but Cook also has more than four times the population. As fragmentation goes, we are the fragmentiest.
OK, that’s not yet a word, but the Oxford English Dictionary added “jagoff” last September. If it would like another coinage from Western Pennsylvania, there’s a county map that would make the perfect illustration.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.