Donald Scanlon bought his home in Shadyside 60 years ago, but it’s only been the past three months that the widower began putting a parking cone out each time he drove to the supermarket.

That’s the only way he can be sure he won’t have to lug groceries a block or more.

If you want to know why more than 1,000 people, mostly in the East End, have signed petitions for an indoor ice rink in the old Hunt Armory, look beyond the love of skating and hockey.You need to know that almost three-quarters of Shadyside is devoted to rental units already, and parking is often harder to find than humility at a presidential debate.

Thus a rink looks a lot better to the petitioners than adding 106 more apartments, most of them one-bedroom, to one of the city’s most densely populated neighborhoods.

Advertise with us

The Urban Redevelopment Authority is expected to vote Dec. 10 to approve one of three proposals for the massive century-old armory on Emerson Street: apartments, collaborative office space or an ice rink. Not long ago, the city might have begged to get any of the three, but it can now be choosy and it has promised to listen to the community’s desires.

Kevin Acklin, Mayor Bill Peduto’s chief of staff and chairman of the URA, said more than 1,000 emails, phone calls and letters have arrived in favor of an ice rink.

Virginia Flaherty is among its proponents. She still lives about five doors down from her girlhood home on Lehigh Avenue, a few blocks west of the armory. The youngest of five children — the oldest being Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Tom Flaherty — she went to Sacred Heart grade school across from the armory in the 1960s and ’70s.

Thus she knows politics and the neighborhood. On Election Day, she went to the polls at Calvary Episcopal Church on Shady Avenue, just a long slap shot from the armory, and in three hours collected 160 signatures of people saying they wanted a rink and not more apartments.

The apartment plan from Walnut Capital, which owns 2,500 residential units in Pittsburgh, calls for fewer parking spaces than apartments. Residents can envision the parking overflow from new residents and visitors clogging Emerson, a street that has been the cordoned-off lunchtime playground for Sacred Heart schoolchildren for generations.

Advertise with us

Sister Lynn Rettinger, Sacred Heart principal, says her preference is the rink, which will have 140 inside parking spaces and a promise from its developer to maintain the play zone. The Rev. Jonathon Jensen, rector of Calvary Episcopal, feels the same way. The rink actually adds parking, won’t be heavily used when school is in session, and it would be in keeping with the building’s historic role as a community center, he said.

Indeed, the building has seen everything from a Billy Graham crusade to a Led Zeppelin concert within its walls. Now the community wants back in, and the groundswell for an ice rink extends beyond Shadyside.

Maggie Cook and her husband John Prodan, owners of the Frick Park Market in Point Breeze, have been encouraging patrons to contact Mr. Peduto (a hockey player himself) and East End Councilman Dan Gilman to push the rink. The city should consider more than short-term financial gain, she said.

“People don’t know who their neighbors are anymore,” Ms. Cook said. A place where people can go to skate, walk a track around the rink and socialize would increase everyone’s quality of life.

The city’s hockey players currently have to drive to the burbs if they want to play. Steven Berman, 49, is a Squirrel Hill resident who took up the game at 37 after moving here from Miami. He now plays year-round, offers beginners lessons to children each winter at the Schenley Park rink, but has to drive at least 30 minutes to get to any indoor rink.

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania Interscholastic Hockey League starts games as late as 9:40 p.m. to accommodate the region’s teams, and Mr. Berman says his adult league at the IceoPlex at Southpointe has to play games 10 to 13 days apart. It’s little wonder his online petitions to back a year-round rink in Shadyside have garnered more than 1,000 names.

Mr. Acklin made no commitment but promised the city is listening. Every luxury-apartment development seems to increase the demand for more, but “we don’t want a city with shiny new housing but regular people can’t afford to live here,” he said.

The final word can go to John Flaherty, 89, Ms. Flaherty’s father. She quoted him saying that taxpaying citizens of the city carried the armory for a hundred years while it was tax-exempt. Now that the building is headed for the tax rolls, the least the city can do is give the residents what they most want and need.

Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947.

Correction (posted Dec. 3): This column has been updated with the correct spelling of The Rev. Jonathon Jensen, rector of Calvary Episcopal Church.