Once a storage center for weapons and ammunition, the Hunt Armory in Shadyside soon may become the domain of ice skates and slap shots.

Bowing to public sentiment, Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority board members voted 4-1 Thursday to begin 90 days of exclusive negotiations with Kratsa Properties and Cadan Inc. on a plan to convert the armory into an ice rink.

The decision came after dozens of Shadyside residents and some from nearby neighborhoods packed the board’s meeting room to voice support for the concept. They applauded at the conclusion of the vote.

“This is our dream,” said Virginia Flaherty, a Shadyside resident who organized a petition drive and other activities in support of the rink.

Advertise with us

Walnut Capital and Massaro Properties had proposed 106 apartments, most of them one-bedroom, for the property. McKnight Realty Partners and Mosites Co. had proposed a business incubator.

The rink decision did not come without some concerns about the viability of the proposal.

Board member Jim Ferlo, a former state senator who nominated the armory for a city historic designation, described the Kratsa/​Cadan plan as “completely inadequate.”

He unsuccessfully lobbied the board to do a new request for proposals geared specifically toward recreational reuses of the building.

“Hopefully I’m wrong, the developer can meet the conditions, and everybody will be satisfied,” he said.

Advertise with us

Other board members acknowledged having concerns about the plan but ultimately decided to vote for it, given the overwhelming public support.

Member Cheryl Hall-Russell said she found the plan “appealing” but stressed she didn’t want to see the ice rink close after 18 months.

Kevin Acklin, URA board chairman and chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto, an amateur hockey player himself, said that if the city is serious about doing community-driven development, “we have to listen to what the residents are saying.”

The negotiating period will give the URA a chance to further assess the plan’s viability.

In recognition of the concerns, the board is requiring Kratsa/​Cadan to meet 17 conditions, including a minimum purchase price of $1.86 million, the appraised value, and a commitment to complete the project without public subsidy.

Advertise with us

Kratsa/​Cadan was offering $1 million for the Emerson Street property, the lowest of three bidders. It also was projected to generate the least amount of tax revenue.

While the other proposals may have garnered a higher sales price and more tax revenue, “there’s a social return of capital here in terms of having a public space that people can utilize,” Mr. Acklin said.

Other conditions imposed by the board include not seeking any property tax abatements for 20 years, submission of a community outreach plan for low and moderate income areas, and efforts to work with the URA to more “deeply evaluate” the viability of the rink’s business and operation plans.

After the vote, Bill Kratsa of Kratsa Properties said that meeting the conditions and getting the deal done in 90 days would be daunting. “We have our work cut out for us,” he said.

The developers, he said, may turn to foundations and other organizations for help in raising money and fill gaps in the financing.

Advertise with us

They also are working on a plan to create opportunities for disadvantaged youngsters to use the rink, perhaps in partnership with the Penguins.

Mr. Kratsa, who has sold the rinks he operated in the Pittsburgh area, said he got involved in the armory project at the request of Gary Maister of Toronto-based Cadan.

“I’m not here as a developer. I’m here because of hockey, the love of the game,” he said.

Mr. Maister said he was confident the development team would be able to meet the URA conditions.

In addition to the rink, the $12.6 million project would include about 140 parking spaces, a cafe and a possible walking track.

Advertise with us

Judging by the comments of residents, there will be no shortage of customers. Steven Berman, a left winger with the Pittsburgh Net Crashers amateur hockey team, collected more than 1,000 signatures in support of the rink.

He said he now visits four rinks in the region each week, adding the Shadyside venue would also open up possibilities for local schools.

“I can assure you there is a lot of demand for ice,” he said.

The URA has an agreement to acquire the armory from the state for $1. The state must sign off on any sale to a developer and would receive 80 percent of the proceeds.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.